Sciencemadness Discussion Board

KCLO3 by way of H2O + KCL

 Pages:  1    3

Aaron-V2.0 - 17-11-2002 at 00:40

H2O + KCL ---> Electricity---->KCLO3 + 3H

Yes, no?

Mhmm, I'm going to try making a chlorate cell for a weekend project. So far my plan is simply obtain a 5 gallon bucket and get two sheets of stainless steel sheetmetal, each in the shape of a U they will fit between each other within the bucket and will have a bolt welded to the outer plate which will fit through the bucket's wall.

Now then, there's just two things I have to figure out. First is the electrical source, I think a car battery will work because my friend has made a Hydrogen generator which was what I'm making just no KCL in the water. And if a car battery wont work... I can obtain a 12VDC 7Amp transformer.

Then, I have to figure out the amount of H2O to KCL so the three water molecules will release their H and bond the O3 onto the KCL. I'll check my chemistry book...


No...

Aaron-V2.0 - 17-11-2002 at 12:26

It's KCL + H2O --->Electricity---> KCLO3 6H

Not 3H. :)


vulture - 17-11-2002 at 14:54

You'll need one electrode with a high oxygenoverpotential. Iron won't work.
PbO2 is an option and easy to make by electrolysing Pb metal at 3V in dilute H2SO4.

rikkitikkitavi - 17-11-2002 at 23:17

or just opening a small fully charged lead acid battery and recovering the anode.

But not the maintaincefree, a cheap one is the best!

/rickard

Aaron-V2.0 - 17-11-2002 at 23:41

I was thinking that rikki, I know that I can get Mn02 from dry cells but I havent checked if Mn02 is an equivelant (Sp?) of Pb02. I know it wouldnt be hard to get Mn02... That and my dad got angry when I explained what I was doing. :( Say hydrogen gas and he calls it a bomb, make a KNO3/Sucrose smoke mix and he calls it a bomb, tell him your trying to make Ascorbic Acid/Potassium Nitrate mix and it's a non-hydroscopic rifle propellant and he calls it (You guess it!) a BOMB! :(

Gah, I need to ask my friend's father if I can start doing this at his place, I know he'd love helping me do this stuff.

KABOOOM(pyrojustforfun) - 24-11-2002 at 18:47

[url=http://www.geocities.com/CapeCanaveral/Campus/5361/chlorate/chlorate.html]YOU WON'T FORGET THIS GRAT LINK
THIS IS THE BEST ON THE NET
[/url]

lucifer - 25-11-2002 at 12:18

I did make some PbO2 anode, but it’s not an easy job and it did fail a few times.

A very good page is http://huizen.dds.nl/~wfvisser/EN/gsld_EN.html

It is important that the anode is rotating or else you won’t get a good result.

A good anode however will last very long.

Blind Angel - 26-11-2002 at 20:06

This question may look stupid but can Chlorate be used for something else than doing energy

Polverone - 27-11-2002 at 11:12

I'm not sure exactly what you are asking, but chlorates do have uses other than in pyrotechnics and explosives. They can be used in organic synthesis, for example. I know I've seen a procedure that used aqueous NaClO3 plus vanadium pentoxide for oxidation.

Blind Angel - 27-11-2002 at 15:37

Hmm i heard that it was a realy bad oxydizer, but will search more. And also how do u make/find Vanadium Pentaoxide sound like a realy good catalysor

madscientist - 27-11-2002 at 21:28

An acidic solution of sodium chlorate should be useful for organic oxidations. I think that its effects on benzene may be of interest - and hazardous.

lucifer - 28-11-2002 at 14:43

Chlorates are used lot to produce chlorine dioxide for bleaching and disinfecting.

Blind Angel - 28-11-2002 at 15:51

Chlorine Dioxyde, ClO2?
It's not one of the toxic gas use in war?
Anyway, how do i do it with like NaClO3
NaClO3 + X with H in -> ClO2 + NaOH + X ?

Blind Angel - 28-11-2002 at 15:52

Sorry about the thingy i was trying to make he number appears little but dont seam to work and i can't edit

madscientist - 28-11-2002 at 17:30

You needed to use < > signs instead of [ ] signs.

I'm not sure what you're asking exactly, maybe this will answer your question.

Chlorine dioxide can be prepared by reacting oxalic acid with sodium chlorate. It is toxic and explosive (nitrogen dioxide was the dioxide used as a war gas). It is a very powerfully oxidizing gas.

vulture - 29-11-2002 at 10:00

I don't know where you got it, but assuming that KClO3 is a bad oxidizer can very well get you killed. A bad oxidizer wouldn't do anything with P, but it happens to be that KClO3 forms a very sensitive explosive mixture with P.

Contrary to popular belief, KClO4 is a worse oxidizer than KClO3. It's not the number of oxygen atoms that count. In ClO3, chlorine has the oxydation state of +V which is far less stable than +VII (chlorine achieves noble gas configuration when -I or +VII) in ClO4.

frogfot - 30-11-2002 at 15:02

Have anybody heard anything about formation of CCl4 when using graphite electrodes in chlorate cells? I got some diffuse information about that, and try to clear it out before building my little chlorate plant.

Now, CCl4 is carcinogen which is the biggest problem. It's quite inert too, will be hard to decompose it.

Thanks for all inputs.

KABOOOM(pyrojustforfun) - 5-12-2002 at 17:27

I think electrolysis of javelle water would be faster because a lot of energy has already been consumed to make the ClO ions.

Polverone - 5-12-2002 at 19:27

But I don't think hypochlorite is an intermediate on the way to chlorate in this reaction. According to all the documents I can recall, the production of chlorate or hypochlorite is dependent on the temperature and/or pH at which the reaction takes place. Sodium hypochlorite isn't a better intermediate for producing sodium chlorate than sodium chloride is, even though it already has one oxygen atom added.

frogfot - 6-12-2002 at 10:16

One reliable source i've seen, said that ClO- oxidised on anode to ClO3- during the electrolysis, which happens with great rate.
Solution is then warmed to convert the rest of hypohlorite to chlorate.

Polverone - 6-12-2002 at 13:05

Perhaps I'm wrong. Can you point me to a reference?

frogfot - 8-12-2002 at 05:05

Sorry its in Russian :P
But anyway here it is:
http://chembook.narod.ru/Others/KClO3.djv

I'll translate some things:
"In electrolytical production of KClO3, ClO- is oxidised at anode:
6ClO- + 3H2O + 6e- ==> 2ClO3- + 6H+ + 4Cl- + 1,5O2

Process is following: a solution of NaCl 300-310g/liter is electrolysed with iron cathode and graphite anode (without diaphragme), under 40-60*C.
Current dencity on anode 0,03-0,05A/cm2, on cathode - 0,025-0,045A/cm2. To reduce reduction of ClO- on cathode, there is added 5-6g/liter of Na2Cr2O7 and 0,5-0,6g/liter of HCl."

"Ubtained solution is then heated to 90*C, to convert the rest of hypochlorite that wasnt oxidised."

Sorry about my limited language skills :(

madscientist - 19-12-2002 at 19:45

I just electrolyzed 20g of KCl in distilled water for several hours using a graphite anode, a steel electrode, and a 9.6V, 900mAh direct current. When I ceased electrolysis, I added some distilled water to bring the volume of the solution up to 100mL. I brought the temperature down to 0C, and filtered. I then moved the filtering funnel to a different collection flask, and poured hot water through, which dissolved the KClO3, and left most of the fine graphite powder (which came from the anode) in the filter. I boiled off the water in the solution of KClO3 which had passed through the filter paper, and found that I had merely 1.5g of KClO3, which was slightly greyish due to a tiny amount of graphite powder being present.

madscientist - 19-12-2002 at 21:38

I forgot to mention: during electrolysis, the temperature of the solution was from 50C to 90C, usually around 80C.

Just realized that frogfot's earlier question was never answered.

I'm fairly certain that CCl4 is not formed. I have not noticed formationg of CCl4 in experiments, and carbon is not known to directly react with chlorine.


rikkitikkitavi - 20-12-2002 at 10:52

I do think that ClO- is a intermediate in the reaction.

At the right pH (6-7) there is enough
HClO in solution for the following reaction to take place

(1) 2HClO + ClO- => 2 HCl (aq) + ClO3-

This is the most economical route to ClO3-, seen from energy consumtion.

Other possible ways are direct oxidation at the anode or through intermediates like ClO-, ClO2- e t c but they all consume more energy per mole ClO3-. Industry therefore use regular pH checks on the electrolyte to keep energy consumtion low.

madscientist, one reason why you had a crappy yield could be that any Cl2 formed at the anode escaped from the solution before it could react with the OH- formed at the cathode.

(2) Cl2 + 2OH- = ClO- + Cl- + H2O

Some reduction of ClO3 also take place at the cathode, lowering the final content of ClO3- in solution. But this later will be an equlibrium.

If you titrate the solution and determine the KOH content it would be very interesting. I also had similar results when I experimented with chlorate production.

Keeping temperature below 40 C reduces graphite anode erosion, however reaction (1) proceeds slower.

One idea could be to use a high concentration of KCl in the electrolyte so that any KClO3 formed preciptates, thus preventing it from reducing at the cathode. Solubility of KClO3 in high conc KCl is very low..

Comercial chlorate cells use NaCl at about 300-350 gr/l.

There is several patents describing how additives like persulfates and fluorides reduces cathodic reduction too. (dont have the number right now)

/rickard

Theoretic - 1-7-2003 at 06:55

How, apart from making the solution alkaline at the start or waiting for it to turn alkaline, can one reduce the amount of Cl2 escaping?:o

frogfot - 13-7-2003 at 20:15

Increasing anode surface.

another thread on chlorate

chemoleo - 26-7-2003 at 21:09

i thinks its called
sodium and potassium chlorate. was recent

markx - 7-8-2003 at 04:04

Put the anode at the bottom of the cell and the cathode just beneath the surface of the electrolyte!
That creates a reaction zone in the middle of the cell as the alkali floats down and chlorine rises up.
That works great for eliminating the escape of Cl2.

vulture - 8-8-2003 at 03:05

Duh! Good idea. Amazing how our minds can be restricted by always seeing those chemistry textbook pictures where the electrodes are positioned upright.:o

CCl4 does form with electrolysis of molten chlorides because of the high temperatures and inert atmosphere used.

CF4 also forms to some extent when making Al from molten kryolithe.

But I doubt it will form in aqeous solution.

BTW, CCl4 isn't that bad. It's a victim of the well known chemofear phenomenon. It has been used in lab fire extinguishers in the past and those lab assistants didn't have a particulary high cancer toll.

[Edited on 8-8-2003 by vulture]

KClO3 by Pt, Ti, KCl, H2O and electricity

axehandle - 24-10-2004 at 06:22

http://species8472.dyndns.org/chem/KClO3/index.html

Thought I'd share some porn pictures of my <b>successful</b> KClO<SUB>3</SUB> cell using Pt and Ti with a saturated KCl solution...

neutrino - 24-10-2004 at 07:17

Those look like good yields. I take it that you've had a lack of success with the PbO<sub>2</sub> electrodes?

axehandle - 24-10-2004 at 07:46

Quote:

Those look like good yields. I take it that you've had a lack of success with the PbO2 electrodes?

Not at all, not at all, I'm still trying. I just wanted some ultra-pure (not contaminated by PbO<SUB>2</SUB>;) KClO<SUB>3</SUB> for use in a couple of percussion sensitive mixtures I'm very keen to try...

KClO3

MadHatter - 24-10-2004 at 15:39

I couldn't resist responding to this thread given past experience in making chlorates and
perchlorates.

Vulture, mon ami, I'm glad you're responding to this thread. Your knowledge and
experiences are much needed here. Chlorates are indeed very powerful oxidizers.
Bad oxidizers ? No way ! Along the lines of your response, chlorates mixed with P or S
are unpredictable and dangerous. 30 years ago I blew off my eyebrows with KClO3 and
P - known as Armstrong's mixture. Most experienced pyros are familiar with that mix.

Frogfot, I've never detected the formation of CCl4 when making chlorates/perchlorates -
just that irritating chlorine gas. This is with gouging rods from a welding supply shop.

Rikkitickitavi, the salts you mentioned provide some cathodic protection but also
increase the efficiency of the cell. In the past, I've used potassium dicromate for this
purpose, but the fluorides and persulphates work much better for perchlorate production.

Markx, what you posted is obvious. The problem is finding an anode that won't be
corroded by the brine when completely submerged. I would LOVE to have an anode
with that capability !

Aaron-V2.0, manganese dioxide will work. but how will you get it into a usable shape ?

MadScientist, ClO2 was used a few years ago to kill the anthrax spores in the offices
of a few U.S. Senators. I don't know how the exterminators produced it but I'm sure
it would be interesting to the rest of us to produce this gas without the risk of explosion.

Last but not least, Axehandle, are you sure those are crystals of KClO3 ? In my own,
experience, KClO3 crystals look like cactus needles. From your picture, it looks more
like the rhombic KClO4 crystals. Just an observation !

Anyway, just a few observations and comments. I wish everybody the luck and
success in their scientific endeavours ! If it appears that I'm talking out of my ass,
PLEASE, don't hesitate to flame me ! I'd rather be be flamed than have something
send me to an early grave ! Thanks Again !

tom haggen - 24-10-2004 at 19:20

I'm kind of new to electrolysis, so I'm going to ask a few basic questions on this thread. Basically I can take a 9v battery hook up the negative wire to a PbO2 anode, and a positive wire up to a graphite cathode, stick both of them in a solution of K and Cl ions and presto I have Hydrogen and KCLO3?

The_Davster - 24-10-2004 at 19:36

That would work, but it would take a very long amount of time. The amperage emitted by a 9v battery(I am assuming you mean one of those smal .5"x1"x2" sqare ones) is not enough to produce chlorate at a reasonable rate.
ne=IT/F, where ne is moles of electrons, I is amps, T is time, and F is faraday's constant, 96500 C/mol
So the higher the amperage, the more moles of electrons produced and thus the more chlorate/perchlorate is produced.

chemoleo - 24-10-2004 at 19:47

Don't forget, most importantly, the reaction vessel has to PREVENT THE NASCENT CHLORINE FROM ESCAPING - because of the DESIRED reaction of the freshly produced chlorine with the freshly produced KOH!, forming KOCl, which disproportionates eventually to KClO3 and KCl (where KCl is electrolysed to KOH and Cl2 once again).
That is the most important rule. If you let the chlorine gas escape, then you will PREVENT the electrolysis from performing in the desired manner!

[Edited on 25-10-2004 by chemoleo]

Escaping chlorine

MadHatter - 24-10-2004 at 22:50

Chemoleo, I couldn't have said better myself ! The more the chlorine escapes, the less the
chlorate/perchlorate produced ! Also the brine becomes more alkaline(rising PH) as the Cl2
escapes.

In a previous post, someone talked about keeping the anode completely submerged.
DUH ! We would have done this already if it was possible ! So mark x, a little more practical
application and less theory would go a long way here !

axehandle - 25-10-2004 at 07:25

Quote:

Last but not least, Axehandle, are you sure those are crystals of KClO3 ? In my own,
experience, KClO3 crystals look like cactus needles. From your picture, it looks more
like the rhombic KClO4 crystals. Just an observation !

No, I'm not sure at all. Should be impossible though since I made it straight from KCl and the crystals precititated/crystallized out at the bottom of the vessel. Btw, the crystals in the pictures are really lumps of smaller crystals. Some of them are rod-shaped, some of indeterminable shape. I'll have to look closer, or perhaps try to decompose any KClO<SUB>3</SUB> with HCl, leaving the KClO<SUB>4</SUB>, if any... hmm.

Quote:

I'm kind of new to electrolysis, so I'm going to ask a few basic questions on this thread. Basically I can take a 9v battery hook up the negative wire to a PbO2 anode, and a positive wire up to a graphite cathode, stick both of them in a solution of K and Cl ions and presto I have Hydrogen and KCLO3?

No, if you hook up the negative wire to the PbO<SUB>2</SUB> anode, you'll end upp dissolving the anode. Try the positive wire :).

Leaving your probable typo aside, a battery wouldn't last 10 minutes. You need amps upon amps for days even with a small 1 liter cell such as mine.

Quote:

Don't forget, most importantly, the reaction vessel has to PREVENT THE NASCENT CHLORINE FROM ESCAPING - because of the DESIRED reaction of the freshly produced chlorine with the freshly produced KOH!, forming KOCl, which disproportionates eventually to KClO3 and KCl (where KCl is electrolysed to KOH and Cl2 once again).
That is the most important rule. If you let the chlorine gas escape, then you will PREVENT the electrolysis from performing in the desired manner!

I've tried to make the escape vents (actually, electrode holes in the lid) as small as possible. Still, I must have at least a small opening, otherwise the cell would go boooom...

tom haggen - 25-10-2004 at 11:18

What about that ignition coil driver lab on power labs? Would that be a good source for a high amp, direct current flow?

axehandle - 25-10-2004 at 11:37

Quote:

What about that ignition coil driver lab on power labs? Would that be a good source for a high amp, direct current flow?

Certainly not! An ignition coil delivers a an extremely high voltage at an extremely low amperage. Ideal power sources for a (per)chlorate cell are an ATX PSU, a car battery charger or for a huge cell, a DC welding transformer.

tom haggen - 25-10-2004 at 14:30

So for making my PbO2 anode I just connect a piece of lead to a positive chare and put it in a bath of strong sulfuric acid. Maybe use copper as my cathode? All so I saw someone bitching about thier KClO3 being contaiminated with PbO2. couldn't you simply filter the PbO2 out of the KClO3 solution? Oh ya so could I use copper and PbO2 instead of graphite and PbO2 in my chlorate cell?

[Edited on 25-10-2004 by tom haggen]

Chlorates/Perchlorates

MadHatter - 30-10-2004 at 17:57

tom haggen, definitely lower voltage. Axehandle, you said the some of the crystals
were "rod" shaped. Probably the chlorate crystals. The rhombic crystals are ususally
perchlorate. Easy to separate due to the solubility differences.

Axehandle, do you have access to HCl and, more importantly, indigo carmine ?

Good job on your response to tom haggen's post ! I remember seeing a website on a
German company who produced sodium chlorate directly from a salt mine. It appears
they sent the brine up from the mine directly to chlorate cells constructed of concrete and
using graphite. The "push" was less than 5 volts although the amperage was higher
than hell. Talk about efficient !


[Edited on 31-10-2004 by MadHatter]

Magius - 1-11-2004 at 20:05

Mad Hatter I fail to see why you cannot completly submerge a PbO2 anode in the solution. Perhaps it is my own limited knowledge, but it seems to me that if you set up a cell where the anode and cathode are protruding into the cell from the sides, anode below and cathode above, as long as those whole are sealed with some no-conductive sealent, the cell should be fine. The only other problem with that set up is the excess of corrosion at the point where the electrodes enter the cell, and in my experiance they break off. I'm thinking this could be fixed by slanting the ends of them so that the ends are closer together than from the begining of the cell. That would make it "easier" for the electrolysis to occur at the ends and would corrode it there, rather than at the junction. I don't know, maybe that thinking doesn't hold.


On PbO2 electrodes, I just recently cracked open an old car battery(used). Fron what I've read about them the fail becuase the anode and cathode are coated by PbSO4, stopping the elctrolysis. Yet when I ran current through them in an NaCl solution, the pleasent smell of chlorine filled the room.

I am however, having problems telling the Pb from the PbO2. I've fully removed one of the 6 cells. In it i found the electrode side by side, but one of them was covered in a removable plastic sheath. One of them has a thin white layer on it, and I'm thinking that this would be the PbO2 as the SO4 ion would be attracted to the positive lead ions coming off of it. Both are on fairly maleable, are

I don't know, I feel like I'm missing something in that logic, but my tired mind cannot grasp it at the moment.

Any idea's are welcome, its interesting that something so cool can be made out of such easily available and not so expensive materiel.

axehandle - 3-11-2004 at 17:22

Quote:

Mad Hatter I fail to see why you cannot completly submerge a PbO2 anode in the solution. Perhaps it is my own limited knowledge, but it seems to me that if you set up a cell where the anode and cathode are protruding into the cell from the sides, anode below and cathode above, as long as those whole are sealed with some no-conductive sealent, the cell should be fine. The only other problem with that set up is the excess of corrosion at the point where the electrodes enter the cell, and in my experiance they break off. I'm thinking this could be fixed by slanting the ends of them so that the ends are closer together than from the begining of the cell. That would make it "easier" for the electrolysis to occur at the ends and would corrode it there, rather than at the junction. I don't know, maybe that thinking doesn't hold.
...

Intractable, IMHO --- it's nigh impossible to find a sealant that would 1) be resistant to the Cl<SUB>2</SUB> and anodic oxidation as well as 2) would provide tight enough fit to stop the brine crawling out along the electrode by capillary action and 3) would adhere to both the PbO<SUB>2</SUB> layer on the electrode as well as the hole in the cell wall.

I could be wrong though.

Hermes_Trismegistus - 3-11-2004 at 21:18

glass to metal seal

Sealants and Slant Angles

MadHatter - 6-11-2004 at 13:33

Axehandle, excellent reply to Magius ! Every sealant I've checked the MSDS on so far
shows reactivity hazards with OXIDIZERS. Even the water-resistant silicone sealant has
this problem.

Magius, the slant angle does work. I place the 2 rods in parallel separated by 4 inches. The
cathode is on the top. This way the Cl2 rises to meet the hydroxide forming at the top.
Still, some of the Cl2 escapes.

The other idea I've considered is to cover the top end of the anode with a non-conductive
material so that the exposed end would remain completely submerged. I wouldn't
get the full surface area of the anode as a result but if I could retain most of the Cl2
in the brine I should get more efficient cell even if it means using 2 anode rods.

I saw a seller on eBay selling sheets of graphite. Might make an interesting cathode.

mark - 8-11-2004 at 21:25

In my recent experiments with the preparation of chlorates I turned to electrolysis. I simply used a beaker with two graphite electrodes and a saturated NaCl solution. So after around a day of fizzing it finally stopped. So I took the solution out of the beaker and into a filter. This was than placed in a stainless steel bowl and boiled down on an open flame. My girlfriend came around a little unexpected and I got distracted. When I finally came back I noticed that the White powder was turning black and reddish brown. I let it cool and scooped some of this powder out and mixed it roughly with sugar and one with charcoal neither burnt. So I have come to ask is there away to see if I have made chlorate?

I also noticed something weird. There is a thread about making your HCl by electrolysis a solution of NaCl to get H2 at one electrode and Cl2 at the other. Then burning them to get gas and bubbling it through water.

Electrolysing to get chlorate should be as follows

NaCl + 3H2O -> NaClO3 + 3H2

The only gas that should be involved is H2 but I noticed one electrode bubbled greatly and the other just bubbled a tiny bit. Why?

So under what conditions do each reaction occur.

hodges - 9-11-2004 at 15:29

I see several problems here, Mark.

1. The reaction should not "stop fizzing". Were you using a battery that may have went dead? It takes a lot of current to produce just a little bit of chlorate from chloride, so if you were using a battery anything smaller than a car battery that is one problem.

2. Chlorine and sodium hydroxide are produced as intermediate products at the anode and cathode respectively. You must provide a way to continuously mix the two or else the chlorine will escape and you will not get the reaction you want.

3. Generally the temperature must be somewhat elevated above room temperature for the desired reaction to occur. If you have enough current flowing, usually this will take care of itself. But if you are using a small battery, it will not.

4. In order to separate the chlorate from the remaining chemicals (chloride and hypochlorite), you must add a potatium salt and chill the resulting solution. Potassium chlorate has a very low solubility at low temperatures so it will precipitate out. If you just evaporate everything you are going to get a mixture of products and the main ones are not likely to be your chlorates.

Hope that helps.
Hodges

mark - 9-11-2004 at 22:40

I am using a 10 v 1 Amp dc current. It’s an adopter from something not sure what though.

Well this project started as way to get chlorine for organic hypochlorites. But not much happened so I decided might as well get some chlorate from it.

The temperature was at around 40 degrees most time.

Could I use KNO3 in the separation process?


Also thanks for the help!

hodges - 10-11-2004 at 14:55

In theory, I believe you should be able to use potassium nitrate. Trouble is, potassium nitrate itself is not very soluable in cold water, so some of it will precipitate out as well.

Your power supply is rated at 1A, but I wonder how much current you were really drawing. When I have make KClO3 using electroloysis before, I get significant erosion of the anode (positive electrode) by the time the reaction is complete. Did you also get this? If not, I doubt you had enough current for long enough to produce much KClO3.

mark - 10-11-2004 at 16:43

Well, no there was not a significant amount of erosion. There was a small amount of graphite hanging around in the beaker. The amount of water I used was 250 to 300 ml but by the time it was finished was more around 100 – 150ml. Also I am not sure what else I was producing no Cl2 gas was present to great even noticeable amount.

ClO3

MadHatter - 11-11-2004 at 21:28

Mark, that's 10 watts if your voltage and current numbers are correct. I use a battery
charger, 6 volts X 15 amps = 90 watts in my 10 litre cell. Your voltage seems a little high but
not unreasonable. As for boiling down, use glass, NOT METAL !. The hypochlorite in your
solution would decompose into chlorate and chloride at boiling but the reddish brown
color you mentioned was probably the chlorate oxidizing the iron in your bowl.

A couple of tips: During the electrolysis you should keep the brine at a constant volume
in the cell. Top off periodically with more brine as the cell level drops. Again, boil down
in glass. Find a lower voltage power source if possible.

As for testing for the presence of ClO3, read this:

Indigo Carmine is used for microscopical staining (similar to the methylene blue)
It will have to be purchased from a lab supply store. It is fairly expensive per gram but you will only need a few grams for to do alot of tests. This test in used in US Patent No. 2,392,769.
This test is extremely sensitive and will detect Chlorate levels down to parts per million.
A sample of the electrolyzed cell solution is added to a test indicator made of one gram per litre indigo carmine. The test is made by mixing 1ml of the indigo carmine with 5ml of concentrated Hydrochloric acid, and the mixture heated to boiling, To this boiling mixture, 5ml of the cell solution are added. Five parts per million of Chlorate will cause a sharp decoloration of the indicator, and one part per million can be detected.

I use this test when making perchlorates. Attached is 3 pictures of a test I did less
than 1 hour ago. I dissolved .01 grams of KClO3 in 10 ml water as the solution to
"test". In the 3 pictures from left to right.

Picture 1 shows my 250 ml reagent bottle of indigo carmine indicator. This was made by dissolving .25 grams of indigo carmine in 250 ml distilled water. It's a dark blue liquid.

Picture 2 shows a 50 ml beaker. In it contains 5 ml indigo carmine indicator and 25 ml
31% HCl(purchased at Ace Hardware). The 5-to-1 ratio of HCl to indicator is maintained.

Picture 3 shows what happened after boiling the beaker and adding 3 DROPS of the "test"
solution.

IC-HCl-ClO3.jpg - 240kB

tom haggen - 1-2-2005 at 10:13

I'm having a hard time figuring out how to design my cell. Could I just get a couple of pieces of plexy glass from the hard ware store and seal them with the sealant you use on fish tanks or something? Also, where the heck could I find a piece of graphite to use for a cathode? Also, how much gas pressure do you guys think will build up inside the cell? Could I use PV=nRT to calculate the atm. pressure?
How do you know when you have converted all of the KOCl to KClO3?


[Edited on 1-2-2005 by tom haggen]

Mumbles - 1-2-2005 at 18:42

Graphite can be found as gouging rods, or golf club shafts. I've seen them around for electrolysis too, but I think these were quite a bit more expensive than a good gouging rod or gold club shaft.

Don't quote me on this, but I think you can tell when it's done when it starts to electrolyse the water.

neutrino - 1-2-2005 at 18:59

Golf club shafts? Even if you could get rid of the plastic matrix, all you’d be left with is flimsy carbon fiber. Surely you couldn’t make a good electrode out of this?

markgollum - 1-2-2005 at 20:25

I have a chlorate cell (actually three in series) that I am very happy with.
It has a combined capacity of 1.5L and usually produces 450g of KClO3 every 2.5 days that I run it, with minimal anode wear.
The cell bodies are ABS pipe plugged at one end with the proper adapters, the overall length (not including the square, screw on part of the bottom) is 28 cm and the OD of the pipes is 6 cm.
Each cell has 5 electrodes, 4 graphite anodes "gouging rods" and a central, threaded, stainless steel cathode (34cm long). The 5 electrodes are held in place by two polycarbonate circles, one a few cm from the top of the ss rod, and he other at the bottom.
Each of the polycarbonate circles has 5 holes drilled in it, one in the centre for the ss rod, and 4 evenly spaced around it for the graphite anodes. The polycarbonate circles are held in place by two ss washers and two ss nuts that are threaded onto the ss rod. The entire electrode assembly fits into the ABS pipe. Three of these cells are wired in series, and using an ultra heavy duty battery charger/car booster capable of 150A @ 12V a current of 6-10A flows depending on the temperature of the cells (after a few hours the cells start to slowly boil), the amount of electrolyte, and the ion concentration.

Problems I have had and fixed.

1. It is very hard to make a good connection between copper wire and the ss rod even if I wrapped the wire around the threaded rod inside the threads there would be very small arcs and the top of the rod would almost get red hot.

Solution,

Copper tubing the same diameter of the SS nuts, and 4cm long was placed over the top of the SS rod, soldered to the wire, and filled with molten lead. Problem solved.

2. Corrosion of the Cu wire connected to the graphite anodes.
The wire was painted with anti rust paint and the entire top of the cell potted in wax. Just did that yesterday hope it works.

Tips

If you break a graphite rod fix it by pressing the two pieces together, tightly wrapping bare Cu wire 1cm above and below the break, and then carefully coating the wire with epoxy.

A common complaint about C anodes is that they erode quickly. But if you give them the linseed oil treatment, and run them at a low current density, they will last 4-5 times as long.

searat - 8-2-2005 at 21:37

I'am have some troulbe with my cell, i have some KCL,water,cabon electrode, i was wondering how do i seperate KCL and KCLO3?

How do i know if its working, as i smell CL?

[Edited on 9-2-2005 by searat]

Polverone - 9-2-2005 at 02:06

KCl is far more soluble in water than KClO3. That's how you can separate them. We already have extensive discussion of chlorate cells on this site; click the Search link, type in "chlorate," and look at the results before asking very basic questions like this.

gtacchi - 22-2-2005 at 04:49

GUYS, BE CAREFUL!

KClO3 is a strong oxydizer and unstable. It's used to make matches and fireworks. In fireworks it's used to produce flash powder, and is low explosive but much powerful. The main cause of deaths in the industry of fiereworks is because of flash powder.

:o:o:(:o:o

gtacchi - 22-2-2005 at 04:50

I almost forget.

The main route to produce chlorates and perchlorates is by eletrochemistry. :):)

neutrino - 22-2-2005 at 14:18

I’m sure that everyone here knows what he’s doing. Chlorates and Perchlorates aren’t really explosives in their own right, but mainly oxidizers. Most of the energy from flash powder is from the aluminum part, by the way.

searat - 25-2-2005 at 05:52

i'am not to good with fomula equations, can this be corected please.

NaCl + OH -- NaHClO
NaCl + OH - NaOH + CL
2NaCL + 2H2O - 2NaOH + (2CL +H2) = HCL

I,ve being trying this and i get a alot of NaHCLO, if a heat this, will it produce NaCLO3 + NaOH + CL?

[Edited on 25-2-2005 by searat]

12AX7 - 4-4-2005 at 11:21

Here's my ugly-assed, for-the-hell-of-it cell (electrolyzing ice melter, probably half and half NaCl KCl). No idea what voltage (half wave rectified, doh) or current it's running at, as we seem to be out of working DMMs at the moment. :(

(Shoulda taken the pic an hour ago, the yellow ppt was much more interesting than the now black crud. BTW what is it? I'm not familiar with copper (from the Cu'd graphite rods) making yellow compounds.)

Tim

Chlorate.jpg - 60kB

Graphite

MadHatter - 4-4-2005 at 23:20

12AX7, peel that copper plating off the rods before using them. As for the yellow
precipitate, I honestly don't know what to tell you. If it had been green then I could
safely say that it was caused by the copper.

P.S. Still waiting on that goddam kiln to arrive so I can "high fire" and test some
TiO2 rods for perchlorates !


[Edited on 5-4-2005 by MadHatter]

neutrino - 5-4-2005 at 13:05

You seem a bit confused, searat. There is no such thing as NaHClO. The compound you’re referring to is sodium hypochlorite, NaClO. It undergoes thermal decomposition to NaCl and NaClO<sub>3</sub>.

Cyrus - 19-5-2005 at 15:38

So, I take it titania (TiO2) is conductive, MadHatter? I might be able to get some from the local pottery supplier and try to fuse it. I know this is a really simple question, and I probably ought to know the answer, but why are PbO2, TiO2, and Fe3O4 conductive? :)

I wonder if fusing the Fe3O4 with a bit of SiO2 would help it stick together? (Or TiO2 with something like Na2O)

12AX7 - 19-5-2005 at 16:03

IIRC, they say PbO2 is conductive because it is nonstoichometric. I know matter-of-factly titania is nonohmic, you can only use titanium for cathodes. It anodizes quite nicely, OTOH.

Come to think of it, if you wanted a thick layer of TiO2, you could hard anodize it to a few hundred volts or so. Apparently, it is performed in basic solution, and the thickness determines the color (interference). Heat colors titanium similarly.

Tim

12AX7 - 19-5-2005 at 17:46

As long as this thread's up in the air, I'll post my new cell...

Electrodes are graphite plates about 1/8 to 1/4" thick, sawn from 9" long 1 1/2" square bars (total of 55" for $30 with shipping, not bad for eBay). Very dusty black business...

Tim

Chlorate2.jpg - 54kB

Cyrus - 19-5-2005 at 19:00

Ok, pardon the ignorance, but non-ohmic means that it doesn't follow ohm's law, I take it. And why would this mean that it can only be used as a cathode?

Hmm.

Anyhow, I fired a bit of Fe3O4 powder to an orange heat (using just my propane torch). The magnetite was mixed with enough sodium silicate solution to make it stick together. Part of it was brushed on paper, and part was extruded as a rod. It formed a reasonably hard solid that made the "clink" noise that ceramics tend to make. The best part was that it was electrically conductive in spots! That means it shows good potential.

[Edited on 20-5-2005 by Cyrus]

12AX7 - 20-5-2005 at 00:33

Yes, the implication being diodes are nonohmic.

Tim

TiO2

MadHatter - 20-5-2005 at 03:02

Wouter's page had talked about using TiO2 on a substrate for what's called a
geodimensionally stable anode. I thought I'd like to try a solid stick instead.

Power

MadHatter - 20-5-2005 at 23:43

12AX7, I forgot to ask, what is the voltage and amperage you're running on that cell ?
In the past I used a 6 volt/15 amp battery charger but I've since acquired a variable power
supply: 0 - 30 volts, 0 - 20 amps. I'll test it out when I get some new rods made up.

12AX7 - 21-5-2005 at 01:14

Ah, that's just an AT power supply with load resistors on the +5 and +12V rails. Should be running around 30A and done in a week's run time or so.

The other PSU I use is an MOT with some 8AWG wire replacing the HV secondary feeding a hefty bridge rectifier (4x 30V 40A dual shottky diodes, removed from other old computer PSUs).

Tim

Cyrus - 24-5-2005 at 16:42

Perhaps I am missing something, but wouldn't it be extremely simple to have the anode completely below the cathode as follows? (see fig. 1 of attachment)

I am thinking of ceramic substrate lead dioxide plated anodes. The problem that Axehandle faced was that they are not very conductive when first being plated after being smeared with PbO2. Couldn't this be solved simply if graphite was mixed with the clay before it was fired? (graphite in amounts of >/=40% by weight will make the ceramic nicely conductive as I found in my kaolin study) As long as it is kept in a reducing atmosphere (pretty simple for good fuel fired furnaces) the graphite on the surface will also stay put. If it's fired in an mildly oxidizing atmosphere, usually the graphite isn't burned away deeper than 1 mm or so, and could still help.

The other problem with ceramic substrates is that the electrolyte leeches through the porous clay and corrodes the electrical attachments unless the PbO2 coating is flawless. How hard is it to achieve a flawless coating? What if a conductive glaze was put over the top of the electrode where the electrical connection was clamped? Electrolytes will not leak through glass. The problem is making the glaze conductive. Would you guys recommend using carbon, tin oxide, magnetite, or what?

Also, to prevent electrolysis from occuring where it wasn't wanted (perhaps the shaft of the electrodes in fig. 2 or 4) a normal glaze could be used, as current would still flow through the conductive graphite core.

Is there any special optimum shape for electrodes? Which is best?(see fig. 2 and 4)

To fabricate the electrodes, I was thinking of just pouring the conductive clay slip over a sheet of plaster of paris, cutting out the shape desired, and then bending it while wet. Making it by hand would work too. Clay is so useful.

Cyrus

And it would probably help if I actually posted the attachment

Cyrus - 24-5-2005 at 16:51



Chlorate cell.bmp - 192kB

Hmm...

12AX7 - 25-5-2005 at 03:39

Nothing wrong with horizontal plates, worth a try I suppose. :) Vertical makes more sense from the point of gasses getting away. You also get easier access to the faces of it, rather than burning one side unevenly.

Glasses are rarely conductive, but you make a good point, Fe3O4 might be possible. Matter of fact, you need to make one (you *do* need to make one...*Jedi wave of hand*). I'd say, 80% Fe3O4 substrate, 20% clay. Might need as much as cone 10, I'll need to see if I can find an FeO-SiO2-Al2O3 phase diagram to see where it melts.

Alternately, graphite fill. Try it!

To prevent leeching, you need a dense ceramic with few pores. You can fire dangerously close to the melting point, you can use a very fine particle size (brute force method: smaller the clay, smaller the pores; pure ball clay is almost shiny after cone 10), you can add melters (borax, lime, soda) to an otherwise refractory body (clay, alumina, silica, graphite) or you can add a protective glaze. I suggest a low-melt glaze applied thinly to the surface so it mostly gets absorbed. You don't want something thick that'll interfere with the conductivity.

Tim

Cyrus - 25-5-2005 at 20:06

Quote:
Originally posted by 12AX7
Vertical makes more sense from the point of gasses getting away. You also get easier access to the faces of it, rather than burning one side unevenly.


Well, I thought the idea was to prevent chlorine from escaping! ;) That's why "markx" (earlier in this thread) proposed horizontal plates. Oh, and to prevent burning one side of the anode, one could only plate one side, which is just dumb, or put another (probably smaller) cathode below the anode...

Quote:

Glasses are rarely conductive, but you make a good point, Fe3O4 might be possible... (silly content removed :P) ...'d say, 80% Fe3O4 substrate, 20% clay. Might need as much as cone 10, I'll need to see if I can find an FeO-SiO2-Al2O3 phase diagram to see where it melts.


I have had only a little success with Fe3O4, but I may not have been firing it high enough.
Oh, and I will try graphite, but your jedi tricks can never make me try magnetite....I probably will though.

I think it will be almost impossible to make a ceramic substrate impervious to the solution, unless it's pretty much fused into a glass. (for me at least) Ball clay has pores, right? After sitting for days and days in the chlorate cell, there has to be some solution adsorbed... Also, the instructions I've seen call for a rough porous substrate so that the PbO2 coat will adhere well! But you could try using ball clay. (after all, you have some, and I don't. You will try ball clay.)

And about the glaze... anyone know anything about conductive tin oxide containing glass? (I saw a post on it somewhere here.)

The_Davster - 7-6-2005 at 16:41

I have been looking around at platinum wire for use as electrodes in a chlorate cell. The electrode will consist of the platinum wire(aprox. 50cm) coiled around a glass tube. My question, is what is the minimum diameter of wire that I should use for this? Large diameter platinum wire is quite expensive unfortunatly:(.

axehandle - 7-6-2005 at 16:47

Quote:

My question, is what is the minimum diameter of wire that I should use for this? Large diameter platinum wire is quite expensive unfortunatly.

Mine was 0.8mm and was very flimsy once hammered flat. It had to be handled with great care to avoid bending it accidentally. But since you're goping to wind it around a dowel, thinner is probably OK. 0.5mm?


[Edited on 2005-6-8 by axehandle]

The_Davster - 7-6-2005 at 17:08

With yours hammered flat, did you ever encounter that slight erosion of the platinum would occur and corrode right through and break the electrode at that place? I figure that I will need around 50cm of platinum wire for the electrode based on a mock-up I did with copper wire. Damn platinum is expensive:o, anyone know any good(cheap) suppliers? I have googled my ass off searching and even made use of google adds.
Below is the electrode I hope to make, I am loosly basing my chlorate cell on the cell design from the site I took this picture from.
http://www.vk2zay.net/article.php/76



EDIT: Damn, can't get image tags working properly.

[Edited on 8-6-2005 by rogue chemist]

[Edited on 8-6-2005 by rogue chemist]

neutrino - 7-6-2005 at 18:29

You can get the wire for a little over spot price on ebay. If you have an anvil, you may want to get a platinum band from a jeweler and hammer away.

axehandle - 8-6-2005 at 13:43

Quote:

With yours hammered flat, did you ever encounter that slight erosion of the platinum would occur and corrode right through and break the electrode at that place?

No, but I only ran the cell for 10 days or so. Isn't the corrosion of Pt supposed to be insignificant until the halt of XCl gets below 10%, BTW? I think I've read that at several places. Then, as long as the chloride halt is kept healthily high and constant by adding KCl+water periodically, the Pt should probably survive for a very long time.

Many "think", "probably" and "should" in that sentence, I know...

Cyrus - 8-6-2005 at 16:25

Well I made some clay substrates for anodes (not fired yet). They were made in a very nice, clean, and simple way.

Put a piece of fine cloth on the counter, then place two thin (3-4 mm thick?) parallel wood slats about 20 cm apart on top of the cloth, stick a hunk of clay (coleman raku clay was used because it's very easily fired, plenty strong, and nicely porous) in the middle of the cloth between the slats. Place another layer of cloth on top, and then use a rolling pin (y'all know what a rolling pin is, right? :P)
to flatten the clay perfectly. "Peel" off the top layer of cloth, then measure out how big the anode will be, and cut it out with a knife, pizza cutter, etc. Let them dry for a few hours, then take off the bottom layer of fine cloth. This method worked perfectly, and I made 4 clay pieces 4 cm x 15 cm, 2 clay pieces (for testing purposes) 3 cm x ~2 cm, and one clay piece 6 cm x 20 cm. These are nice sizes for anodes, right?

The cell I'm hoping to use will have the following specs. (everthing depends on the transformer, which may not be properly tuned, so these may not be exact)

About 4.1 L of solution will be used. (I'll make it at least 5L)

368 W ( 82A @ 4.5 V)

234 cm^2 of anode for current density of 350 mA per cm^2, which is supposedly the best. (I've got plenty of extra anode area so I can lower/raise them)

I don't know the proper current density etc of the cathode. Any ideas? I would use plain steel except for the corrosion, perhaps graphite rods would be better.

(I'm getting some diodes for the power supply. They are expensive. :( (Actually the radio shack diodes were cheaper than the real electronics store diodes)


Cyrus

Cyrus - 8-6-2005 at 20:04

Sorry for the double post, but I have an attachment.

Here's a simple schematic of my power supply. (see attachment)

You'll notice that there's not really any current limiting device besides a fuse. Is this reasonably safe? My concern is that the resistance of the cell could be low enough that components overheat if the electrodes are too close together, etc. But according to Wouter and other sites, there's not really any easy way to measure the current. (I could borrow a good multimeter, but they seem to think I'd need a rms meter) I'd like to have some (cheap of course) way to "dial in" the current so that when testing new configurations, I could slowly increase the current and check to make sure I wasn't giving it too many amps. I haven't bought the diodes yet, and I'm not certain how large they should be. I'm thinking 60-120 A. (I'd use a few smaller diodes in parallel instead of two huge diodes, with a resistor in front of each. )

Also, I'm not certain if I'll need to vary the voltage. I figure that if I set it at, say, 4.5 volts, it should work fine for chlorates and perchlorates, but then again, apparently MOTs have poor voltage regulation. Any ideas? I suppose a few extra taps in the transformer secondary here and there would be a good idea. Might be kind of hard when the secondary only has 4 turns. :)

Edit- Any ideas on what I should ground? The book I read indicated that the negative terminal was grounded in a typical full-wave rectifier.



[Edited on 9-6-2005 by Cyrus]

transformer.bmp - 769kB

The_Davster - 8-6-2005 at 20:35

Any problems with a Pt 92% W 8% alloy? I know a platinum irridium alloy is fine, but I am not sure about a platinum tungsten alloys usefullness in such a cell.

12AX7 - 8-6-2005 at 21:47

Cyrus: bum some dead computer switching power supplies and rip the schottky power diodes. Usually something like 40A 30V. A few in parallel will hold up nicely.

R.C.: I can't find a Pt-W phase diagram in my collection, but I would assume it's either two phases or a solid solution (probably the latter at only 8%). In that case, it ought to have the combined properties of Pt+W. If it is two phase, you'll have either grains of Pt inside a W matrix (unlikely as W has the higher melting point) or W grains in a much wider Pt matrix. The latter would be preferred, I imagine, as W corrosion won't undermine the Pt structure.

Tim

Cyrus - 9-6-2005 at 14:41

Quote:
Originally posted by rogue chemist
Any problems with a Pt 92% W 8% alloy?


Well, the cost. I'd always have to worry about doing something wrong which would ruin the Pt, like getting the chloride conc. below 10%. (I sometimes make mistakes, you know)

So far I've spent about $5 on lead dioxide making, and $4 on the power supply.

Tim, the diodes from a computer power supply sound nice, but I'm not sure where I'd get them, second hand stores perhaps.
Oh, and wouldn't a variable resistor (varistor?) work to control the amperage, like a lamp dimmer?

Wouter mentioned using variacs to tune the voltage IIRC...

12AX7 - 9-6-2005 at 16:15

Quote:
Originally posted by Cyrus
Tim, the diodes from a computer power supply sound nice, but I'm not sure where I'd get them, second hand stores perhaps.


:o :o :o You must not be a dumpster diver!!!

Quote:

Oh, and wouldn't a variable resistor (varistor?) work to control the amperage, like a lamp dimmer?


Uh, I guess. You could also connect a variable inductor in series with the primary. Speaking of which, you should add some primary turns anyway, or a buck transformer - I betcha that MOT runs warm with no load.

Quote:
Wouter mentioned using variacs to tune the voltage IIRC...


Variable autotransformers work wonderfully if you have them!

Tim

evilgecko - 10-6-2005 at 02:16

I would not recommend using varible resistors to control the current needed for a chlorate cell. Pots with 2A+ ratings are very rare and expensive and are extremely good at converting chemical energy into heat!

IIRC light dimmers work by varing the frequency of the AC voltage to control the output power. This is also unsuitable for a DC powered cell.

I think the best way to go would to use the distance (or is it length ;) ) between the electrodes to control current. This means you would have to have movable electrodes which can be a pain in the brain.

Another way is to use a variac, which is what axehandle used for his furnace. Good quality ones are quite expensive though and might empty the pigs belly.

So many decisions so little time...

tumadre - 10-6-2005 at 08:13

your power supply is only as good as the amount of current it can deliver, use a computer power supply, they are the most effective at five volts. It makes no difference whether you increase the distance between the elements in the cell or use resistors in the power supply.

Cyrus - 10-6-2005 at 12:19

Quote:
Originally posted by evilgecko
I would not recommend using varible resistors to control the current needed for a chlorate cell. Pots with 2A+ ratings are very rare and expensive and are extremely good at converting chemical energy into heat!

IIRC light dimmers work by varing the frequency of the AC voltage to control the output power. This is also unsuitable for a DC powered cell.



Oops. I didn't mean a potentiometer, but a rheostat. (bigger) It would be put in series with the primary, of course.
If light dimmers work by varying the frequency of the AC voltage, they could be put in series with the primary winding of the transformer, which is still AC.

Tumadre, I'm not sure what your point is. I'm trying to have a setup where I can increase the amperage (or voltage) gradually from zero up to the desired amount.

Moving the anodes/cathodes around might just be the simplest solution...

[Edited on 10-6-2005 by Cyrus]

Cyrus - 12-6-2005 at 19:03

Well, I decided to use a nice large glass jar (3.5 L capacity if I fill it to within an inch or so of the brim. That is probably too close to the top...)

That means I'll only need about 60 - 70 amps. ;) It also means that the anodes/cathodes will not be very adjustable, because they have to fit inside of a reasonably narrow bottle neck.

According to Wouter Visser, in a chlorate cell graphite anodes run at 30 mA per square cm, while (perhaps it was that geocities place http://www.geocities.com/CapeCanaveral/Campus/5361/chlorate/... ) in a perchlorate cell they run at 200-350 mA per square cm! To those who have made (per)chlorate- what current densities on the anodes and cathodes do you use, and how well did they work? (PbO2 anodes in particular)

Also, which grades of stainless steel are suitable with PbO2? (Chromates can't form as they will ruin the efficiency.)

Edit-

~Grades of SS that are ok are type 347 and food grade is not too bad.
Other alloyes that are good are Durimet 20, Hastelloy HB-1, Hastelloy HC-3, Hastelloy C.
~

(taken from the web address mentioned earlier in this post)

Edit 2- I got a nice looking fluorescent lamp dimmer for $5. Apparently they do work by chopping up the sine wave of the 117 v input. Poor sine wave. Anyways, will this work with the power supply I am envisioning? I suppose the DC output will just be really jagged. (unless I install a large capacitor)

BTW, how the heck am I going to measure how many amps flow through this thing? Some of the multimeters I've seen only go to 250 mA. I could "borrow" a capacitor from a large motor I have, put it across the output to smooth things out, measure the voltages at the output, calibrate the light dimmer using those numbers, and then find the resistance across the cell. Which would depend on temperature, the phase of the moon, etc....:(

[Edited on 14-6-2005 by Cyrus]

Magius - 20-6-2005 at 18:51

Dang Cyrus, sounds like you cell is gonna be awesome. Wish I had the time/patience/chems to make a Lead Dioxide Anode, but my graphite stands up fine after being soaked in linseed oil for 4-5 days.

Since you have a PbO2 anode, and chromates in the cell will screw up your efficiancy, why don't you try getting some Titanium wire? I got 20ft of .883mm wire off ebay for 12$, and I can say for certain that more chloride is absorbed in the cell becuase i was able to spiral the Ti wire around the anode.


On your questions for current density, my averages 300mAmps/cm^2 or so, and the errosion doesn't seem that bad, althought the crystal's that have been forming do get alittle black from erroded graphite. Not sure how your PbO2 anode will hold up, probably much better than a graphite welding rod.

As for the crystal's forming, this is where I've been having some problems. My cell is currently running on KCl, but I think that I may have to switch to NaCl becuase of the crystal creep problems I've been having. Some KClO3 crystalizes out on the bottom of the cell, but a mix of KClO3 and KCl forms as crystal where the anode and Cathode enters into the cell, and when the water is lost, I end up with a large hunk of crystal wedged between my anode and cathode. Just thought I'd like to warn you, (and see if anyone knows a solution) keep the solution level in your cell at least 2 inches below where the anode and cathode enters the Cell, otherwise the crystal will creep out of the Cell and all over the place. Not fun to clean up.

Good Luck

12AX7 - 20-6-2005 at 21:35

Something I've been thinking about, what if you have a long tank. Heat from the electrolysis would set up convection from one end to the other. Hang a basket of coarse salt around the electrodes (to maintain a concentrated chloride solution) and periodically rake the chlorate out of the cool end. Theory being the cyclic heating and cooling of the solution causes soluble salt to dissolve and displace less soluble (and in particular, much less soluble when *cooled*) chlorate, pushing the equilibrium in one direction.

Tim

12AX7 - 24-3-2007 at 22:09

BUMP! :)

I'm starting the season early for a change. My power supply is low on voltage so I'll run it for a few weeks at a time until mid-June arrives. :D

I happen to have this big chunk of stainless steel tubing, so I welded a plate to the bottom (welding must be like riding a bike, I only got one pinhole after the first try :cool:) I've still got two 1.5" square 18" bars of graphite (hmm, I do recall they're 18"...that must mean the cell is actually more like 16", not 20), so I'm just going to be lazy and drop one inside. I cut a bunch of 3/8" long chunks of PVC pipe to cover the bottom so the anode doesn't rest on a short circuit.

Tim

ChlorateCell.gif - 4kB

12AX7 - 10-4-2007 at 17:43

Real picture:



Garbage bag stuffed in the annulus to reduce fumes. Works pretty well! The spring loaded clamp holds a copper strap to the top of the bar, which doesn't corrode too badly considering. The power supply, out of view, is a microwave oven transformer I rewound for low voltage and added some diodes and capacitors to get DC.

And yes, I had just changed out the electrolyte. Gets kinda dirty as you can see. Filters cleanly through packed glass wool.

The propane torch just beside was just being used, incidentially, to cook down the hypochlorite from that run. Having a steel cell is very nice...

Last night I was also recrystallizing some KClO3 I didn't even realize I had. Turns out the last batch was significantly more yield than I had thought -- efficiency WAS good, after all. Here are some unusually large crystals.



Tim

dann2 - 12-4-2007 at 14:27

Quote:
Originally posted by MadHatter

Snipppp


Mark, that's 10 watts if your voltage and current numbers are correct. I use a battery
heated to boiling, To this boiling mixture, 5ml of the cell solution are added. Five parts per million of Chlorate will cause a sharp decoloration of the indicator, and one part per million can be detected.

I use this test when making perchlorates. Attached is 3 pictures of a test I did less
than 1 hour ago. I dissolved .01 grams of KClO3 in 10 ml water as the solution to
"test". In the 3 pictures from left to right.

Picture 1 shows my 250 ml reagent bottle of indigo carmine indicator. This was made by dissolving .25 grams of indigo carmine in 250 ml distilled water. It's a dark blue liquid.

Picture 2 shows a 50 ml beaker. In it contains 5 ml indigo carmine indicator and 25 ml
31% HCl(purchased at Ace Hardware). The 5-to-1 ratio of HCl to indicator is maintained.

Picture 3 shows what happened after boiling the beaker and adding 3 DROPS of the "test"
solution.


Greeting Mad Hatter,

The Chlorate/Perchlorate threads will just never stop....

Would it be OK if I put the pic (of the Inidgo Carmine) on my web site.

Cheers,

Dann2

BUMP!

12AX7 - 28-6-2007 at 17:47

An FYI for the thread:

I have an ammeter of debatable accuracy. Looks like it was for a battery charger or so. The best I ever got with the above setup was 30A, and that's hot (while boiling the solution). Under normal conditions I got about 20A. (This is to about one significant digit, no, not a very useful meter / only "just" useful.)

The other day, I accidentially shorted the power supply, enduring a current in the 60-80A range, which eventually blew a rectifier somewhere (although I didn't find a failed junction when ohming them out later). So, I took it upon myself to use my larger MOT core, which I'm not using for line isolation anymore, and put some heavy wire on it. I also took the liberty of making it a centertapped winding, so I can parallel my two remaining dual diodes, giving some 60A capacity. I also decided to pick off the shelf a rather large inductor I made some years ago, intended for welder duty. It has, I think 8 turns of #0 AWG aluminum wire on a gapped MOT core. It seems to help, reducing ripple to a few volts. The transformer and heatsink run a bit hot (the transformer by design, unfortunately), so I added a reasonable fan (40 CFM?), which is keeping things nice and touchable.

At 60A load, I get 6VDC output, so I added a bit of steel wire ballast in series with the cell, bringing it down to 3.6VDC or so. The cell is now running three times faster, and operating at 65°C (150°F). I should be gathering about three pounds of sodium chlorate per week!

Tim

dann2 - 29-6-2007 at 15:04

Hello,

What is the Anode?
Dann2

 Pages:  1    3