teodor
International Hazard
Posts: 1001
Registered: 28-6-2019
Location: Netherlands
Member Is Offline
|
|
Deep chemistry of metaphosphates
In the fluorine preparation thread I've already mentioned the reaction of sodium metaphosphate with sodium fluoride. The works of madame Remziye Salih
Hisar (just realized she is a woman) looked quite interesting and the chemical reaction in her articles are totally unfamiliar. So I decided to try of
some reactions mentioned by her.
4 NaNO3 + 4 NaPO3 = 2 Na4P2O7 + 4 NO2 + O2
So, I suppose it should be N2O5 but because the reaction is performed in the molten state N2O5 is instantly decomposed.
Let me explain the idea.
There is no such compound as NaPO3. There is a family of cyclic forms from (NaPO3)3 to polymers composing of cycles. Mixture of polymers (NaPO3)n
with high value of n have the name Graham's salt or sodium hexametaphosphate (they sell it by the name of "Calgon" as a water softener by the way.
This story was started with discovery of EDTA and by analogy they found similar properties in metaphosphates. See Oscar Quimby "The chemistry of
sodium phosphates"). "Hexa" is misleading here because it is just one of the building units. The good introduction to the composition of this class of
compounds is
Attachment: audrieth1948.pdf (6.6MB)
This file has been downloaded 26 times
You can see metaphosphoric acids as an endless attempt of H3PO4 dehydration. P4O10 has some particular 3D form which (HPO3)n never can fold to. But it
makes a lot of cycles in plane and in space. When you add water it slowly goes back to H4P2O7.
The interesting thing is that this compound breaks water molecules during hydrolysis. H+ part goes to one part of the broken P-O (-O -> -OH group)
and OH- goes to P forming P-OH.
The reaction with NaNO3 works quite similar, -O part instead of H+ takes Na+ and P takes O-Na.
So, basically, when depolymerisation occurs, O-P connections from cycles becomes O- and P which gets oxygen either from water or from the oxyacid salt
(NaNO3). So, for this type of reaction water and oxyacids (salts) work similar.
So, it sounds quite unusual (for me), so I did a little experiment.
I put 0.21 g KNO3 and 0.39 g (NaPO3)n into a test tube and heated it in a flame of teclu burner.
The first water vapours appeared. It is probably because (NaPO3)n always absorbs some (even if it looks dry).
The second some cracking noise started probably accomplishing KNO3 melting.
And at the third stage a bubbling reaction happens which filled the tube with brown gas.
So, looks interesting. The question how much it goes to completion. So I will plan some quantitative experiments.
(And this thread I designate to discussion of the fascinating chemistry of metaphosphates).
|
|
|
teodor
International Hazard
Posts: 1001
Registered: 28-6-2019
Location: Netherlands
Member Is Offline
|
|
Today I did a fast check of the potential reactions
KHSO4 + 2NaPO3 = Na2KHP2O7 + SO3
and
K2S2O7 + 2NaPO3 = Na2K2P2O7 + 2SO3
in both cases H2SO4 vapors were detected.
I unable to say quantitative comparison of with the reaction
K2S2O7 = K2SO4 + SO3
(both in terms of yield and the temperature required)
but it looks like adding (NaPO3)n into molten K2S2O7 makes a short release of SO3 and the reaction is ceased after several seconds,
while heating K2S2O7 alone requires more time for completion. Reaction with (NaPO3)n goes, as usual, with active effervescence and K2S2O7 alone is
not.
Edit: also in a case of KHSO4 + (NaPO3)n charge the water vapors don't appear as in the case of KHSO4 -> K2S2O7 transition around 300C.
I also checked the potential route to SO2:
Na2SO3 + 2NaPO3 = Na4P2O7 + SO2
but was disappointed. It produces sulfur as vapors and a globe inside the melt and on higher temperature the sulfur globe converts in some black
substance (sulfide?). The reaction is not going to completion easily and the black globe continues to bubble. I need to think about possible route how
sulfur can appear.
There is some smell of SO2 but I can detect its presence only on a cork stopper.
Update: I am not sure the globe is sulfur. I tried to melt my food grade (quite old) Na2SO3 and I've got a dark red liquid. Could be similar to molten
sulfur. I should probably try with purified matherial.
If the reddish-yellow globe is really molten Na2SO3 it could little explain the poor SO2 yield. Probably Na2SO3 is not miscible with (NaPO3)n in the
molten state and the reaction doesn't go as smoothly as in other cases.
Caution: the molten (NaPO3)n forms a glass mass on cooling which breaks a test tube. But in my experiments I always used excess of the methaphosphate
and didn't allow the reaction to go to completion. I would suggest to try the excess of other reagent as a possible way to protect glass.
Update:
My speculation about the reaction mechanism doesn't explain all the the experimental results.
KI + (NaPO3)n -> I2 . Vapours, sublimation of I2 crystalls on the test tube walls
KCl + (NaPO3)n -> Cl2 (?) . The melting temperature is out of range that I use in my test tube experiments, but the mix softens, the smell looks
like dilute HCl ("medical smell") but no smoke. The indicator paper shows strong acid.
Na2S + (NaPO3)n -> H2S. Can't explain that except by the present of water in the reagents.
Update: stupid me. I used CAS 27610-45-3 which is Na2S * xH2O
After dehydration the result is quite different. Some yellow-to orange solid with no/low volatility. I assume a polysulfide mix.
[Edited on 17-3-2025 by teodor]
|
|
|
teodor
International Hazard
Posts: 1001
Registered: 28-6-2019
Location: Netherlands
Member Is Offline
|
|
By the analogy of
2 NaO-NO2 + 2 NaPO3 = Na4[O3P-O-PO3] + O2N-O-NO2
the reaction
2 NaO-CH3CO + 2 NaPO3 -> Na4[O3P-O-PO3] + CH3OC-O-CCH3O
has its right to happen. But I think in the range of temperatures which the molten salts mixture can get the connection of organic molecules could be
less favorable than the more straight way of dehydration:
NaO-CH3CO + 2 NaPO3 -> Na3H[O3P-O-PO3] + CH2=C=O
( It doesn't require connection of 2 remnants).
There is a way of producing Ac2O by dropping AcOH on a heated mixture of (NaPO3)n , NaOAc and diatomes, it was mentioned in the acetic anhydride
preparation thread already. The need of acetic acid probably is explained by the fact that metaphosphate - acetate gives mainly ketene which reacts
with the acid to produce the desired compound.
Reflux of the solution of acetate in acetic acid in presence of metaphosphate theoretically can give similar results (probably much safer and slower)
but 2 practical issues must be solved:
1. Bumping of the acid/salt mixture.
2. Detection of possible unreacted ketene escape.
[Edited on 19-3-2025 by teodor]
|
|
|
teodor
International Hazard
Posts: 1001
Registered: 28-6-2019
Location: Netherlands
Member Is Offline
|
|
After a few days of experiments I can confirm that Graham's salt, CAS 10361-03-2 is extremely powerful drying agent but a peculiar one. For example,
it requires drying before usage and the way it gets to equilibrium is hardly can be compared with other chemicals.
I need several days to systematise the experimental results, after that I plan to publish the first part of them as "getting 100% acetic acid" story.
|
|
|
woelen
Super Administrator
Posts: 8080
Registered: 20-8-2005
Location: Netherlands
Member Is Offline
Mood: interested
|
|
What I read from your posts is that heating (actually fairly strongly) is needed for drying, and that is a very important difference with many other
drying agents (e.g. P4O10, CaCl2, NaOH, CaO). It makes the use of this drying agent for the average home chemist much more difficult, especially
because it also attacks glass quite strongly at the temperatures you mention.
|
|
|
teodor
International Hazard
Posts: 1001
Registered: 28-6-2019
Location: Netherlands
Member Is Offline
|
|
Quote: Originally posted by woelen  | | What I read from your posts is that heating (actually fairly strongly) is needed for drying, and that is a very important difference with many other
drying agents (e.g. P4O10, CaCl2, NaOH, CaO). It makes the use of this drying agent for the average home chemist much more difficult, especially
because it also attacks glass quite strongly at the temperatures you mention. |
My last experiments I did in the range 114-125C in the boiling anhydrous acetic acid media. At this range it can act with differet speed depending on
the compound. It much more eager for sidium ions than for hydrogen ions. So it cannot dehydrate acetic acid alone but it can dehydrate e.g. sodium
acetate solution in acetic acid (fast). The boiling point suggest I was probably able to get 20% acetic anhydride solution as the result of sodium
acetate dehydration at temperature lower than 125C. I continue quantitative part of experiments and if there is at least your interset I'll keep you
informed.
As for aqueous acetic acid it can dehydrate it to 100% where equilibrium between hydrogen pyrophosphate and the acid doesnt cause further dehydration.
This is during several hours and not minutes as in the case of NaOAc.
I think it would be possible the same way to dehydrate some salts if they are soluble in AcOH and not decomposing by the action of metaphosphate. (And
this IF is a very big one. Most of compounds are decomposing by metaphosphate fusion. The question is - at given temperature).
But ones need a reflux setup for such kind of experiments.
The compound in the acid media acts in solid state (Graham's salt is not soluble in the acid), so I don't think it can attack glass.
The product of the reaction (e.g. Na4P2O7) could be soluble. I can check what is the dry residue after I will evaporate acid. But it is not the first
priority. I try to find the most optimal way to dry the compound itself because adsorbed water percent is quite high and part of its power is wasted
to self-dehydration. Which is probably not happening below 100C. That's why I said it is the peculiar drying agent, it can coexist with water at room
temperature.
Boiling in AcOH dehydrates it but then you need much excess for the primary reaction.
If you ever thinking how I can get the amount of water adsorbed - easily, by the acid boiling point drop.
And yes, woelen, you got the point of my latest experiments quite right - the temperature and (re)usage of glass. I can confirm - even suspension at
112-125C works great.
Update: the problem of the high water contents in metaphosphates is mentioned e.g. in Inorganic syntheses, vol 2 or 3, see Na3PO3F synthesis. For that
purpose Audrith recommends trimetaphosphate as starting matherial, and more of that, freshly prepared.
Usage of hexamethaphosphate instead would simplify many reactions if we would be able easily dehydrate it. Reflux in AcOH definitely works, but I feel
should be also another way.
[Edited on 21-3-2025 by teodor]
|
|
|
clearly_not_atara
International Hazard
Posts: 2825
Registered: 3-11-2013
Member Is Offline
Mood: Big
|
|
| Quote: | | The boiling point suggest I was probably able to get 20% acetic anhydride solution as the result of sodium acetate dehydration at temperature lower
than 125C. |
Did you take the bp after distillation or before?
|
|
|
teodor
International Hazard
Posts: 1001
Registered: 28-6-2019
Location: Netherlands
Member Is Offline
|
|
| Quote: Originally posted by clearly_not_atara | | Quote: | | The boiling point suggest I was probably able to get 20% acetic anhydride solution as the result of sodium acetate dehydration at temperature lower
than 125C. |
Did you take the bp after distillation or before? |
This is preliminary results and I have much more questions than that one, and answering that one will require me to answer others and I am not ready
to go so far becase my experiments are still going. There are peculiarities which I need to understand, the high boiling point could be reached only
by some particular order of manipulations. The same components in the reaction miture but mixed in different order and with different reaction history
will not give anything more than 118.2C (doesn't matter how much salt is dissolved). This 118.2C is so stable as an upper limit in most of experiments
that I assume it is the real boiling point of AcOH for my termometer at 770 mmHg air pressure.
Getting more than this requires much attention and explanation of exact conditions of the reaction. After I will be sure about this I will answer your
question.
|
|
|
teodor
International Hazard
Posts: 1001
Registered: 28-6-2019
Location: Netherlands
Member Is Offline
|
|
So, according to my preliminary results and thinking the most serious problem is the equilibriums
2 NaPO3 + H2O <-> Na2H2P2O7
NaPO3 + H2O <-> NaH2PO4
For drying of crude hexametaphosphate I can imagine several ways:
1. By heat. Drawbacks: could change the chemical properties.
2. Dessicator over H2SO4. I think anything more powerful is more expensive or did I miss something? I don't want to dry a drying agent with more
expensive drying agent, it is a nonsense. Drawbacks: none.
3. Washing with AcOH. Drawbacks: only for reactions with AcO-, other reactions would require drying from AcOH.
4. Reflux with AcOH. Drawbacks: equilibriums mentioned at the beginning.
5. Azeotropic distillation (benzene, alcohol, hexane etc). Drawbacks: possible dehydration reaction with some compounds, the solvent residue should
not interfere with further experiments.
I would check all those ways, but having limited time today I started my experiment with the option 2.
The weight of the empty "pralinevormpje" is 0.529g and together with (NaPO3)n (bought from labshop.nl) is 60.645g.
Let's check the mass change in few days.
[Edited on 22-3-2025 by teodor]
|
|
|
LesserLordKusanali
Harmless
Posts: 4
Registered: 25-3-2024
Member Is Offline
Mood: No Mood
|
|
Somewhat related, have you done any experimenting on reducing metaphosphates? the metaphosphate I have quite a bit of is sodium hexametaphosphate. I'm
going to attempt a low temp reduction with liquid lithium and zinc chloride under mineral oil but I was curious if you had stumbled upon anything
since you like metaphosphates so much 
|
|
|
teodor
International Hazard
Posts: 1001
Registered: 28-6-2019
Location: Netherlands
Member Is Offline
|
|
| Quote: Originally posted by LesserLordKusanali | | Somewhat related, have you done any experimenting on reducing metaphosphates? the metaphosphate I have quite a bit of is sodium hexametaphosphate. I'm
going to attempt a low temp reduction with liquid lithium and zinc chloride under mineral oil but I was curious if you had stumbled upon anything
since you like metaphosphates so much |
Reducing to P4? Well, I plan to try with other phosphate but for that I need to study a different part of chemistry, the chemistry of clays. Because
clay retorts have the best reputation for reducing phosphates I think, starting from the end of 17 century. Old people made P4 easily even from their
own pee. It is a shame we lost those noble skills. I mean pottery and glassblowling which every chemist of the old centuries was required to have.
|
|
|
davidfetter
Harmless
Posts: 13
Registered: 8-9-2021
Member Is Offline
|
|
| Quote: Originally posted by teodor | | Quote: Originally posted by LesserLordKusanali | | Somewhat related, have you done any experimenting on reducing metaphosphates? the metaphosphate I have quite a bit of is sodium hexametaphosphate. I'm
going to attempt a low temp reduction with liquid lithium and zinc chloride under mineral oil but I was curious if you had stumbled upon anything
since you like metaphosphates so much |
Reducing to P4? Well, I plan to try with other phosphate but for that I need to study a different part of chemistry, the chemistry of clays. Because
clay retorts have the best reputation for reducing phosphates I think, starting from the end of 17 century. Old people made P4 easily even from their
own pee. It is a shame we lost those noble skills. I mean pottery and glassblowling which every chemist of the old centuries was required to have.
|
Do we have any idea which clays, or anything else about this?
I've done a little scientific glassblowing, nothing fancy or novel, but ceramics are completely new to me in this context. There are glass shops in
big-enough chemistry departments/divisions, but I hadn't heard of specialty ceramics other than those used for the military, and those tend not to be
on site.
|
|
|
clearly_not_atara
International Hazard
Posts: 2825
Registered: 3-11-2013
Member Is Offline
Mood: Big
|
|
Apparently the reaction with NaH gives phosphite salts which can be isolated by using barium. Not sure exactly how the Ba phosphite is extracted but
it's interesting.
https://pubs.acs.org/doi/full/10.1021/acscentsci.1c01381
Hypophosphite was also observed, but was not considered a primary synthetic target.
[Edited on 27-3-2025 by clearly_not_atara]
|
|
|
teodor
International Hazard
Posts: 1001
Registered: 28-6-2019
Location: Netherlands
Member Is Offline
|
|
| Quote: Originally posted by davidfetter | | Quote: Originally posted by teodor |
Reducing to P4? Well, I plan to try with other phosphate but for that I need to study a different part of chemistry, the chemistry of clays. Because
clay retorts have the best reputation for reducing phosphates I think, starting from the end of 17 century. Old people made P4 easily even from their
own pee. It is a shame we lost those noble skills. I mean pottery and glassblowling which every chemist of the old centuries was required to have.
|
I've done a little scientific glassblowing, nothing fancy or novel, but ceramics are completely new to me in this context. There are glass shops in
big-enough chemistry departments/divisions, but I hadn't heard of specialty ceramics other than those used for the military, and those tend not to be
on site.
Do we have any idea which clays, or anything else about this?
|
I have checked ancient reports and I found that they use stone retorts. I saw the photos but have no idea how they were made. But it was before they
found that lead and some other heavy metal phostphates have lower decomposition temperature. Also, usage of alumin(i)um or some other metals instead
of carbon can lower the temperature and reaction time as well.
The problem with glass that even if it will not break during decomposition it will definitely break on cooling. So, ceramic is better but still I see
it only as disposable retorts. So you make a clay with consistence of plasticine, make a retort putting your ingredients inside, then heat it. First
clay hardens than reaction happens. Then you dispose the retort.
As a candidates I would select clays based on phosphates. Let say, aluminium phosphate (poly/meta). With raising of temperature too high it would be
converted to Al2O3, the goal is to find composition which will keep the form at the required temperature range.
@clearly_not_atara: looks interesting, but probably too complex if the final goal is P4 and not phosphite.
[Edited on 31-3-2025 by teodor]
|
|
|
![[*]](images/xpblue/default_icon.gif){kind=icon}
