mananvbhatt
Harmless
Posts: 4
Registered: 9-12-2003
Location: ahmedabad , india
Member Is Offline
Mood: confused , furi
|
|
case study help : an explosion : MEKP
friends , i am from india ,
a student at final year project ,
here at the hot climate of around 42-45 people wanna manufacture MEKP at small capacity and in
small scale industry setup.
i need your help at the point that i have been asigned the project to suggest , implement and commission a small plant for manufacturing this damn
bastard explosive at this much hot climate . people i am working with already have practiced the manufactured this since 4 years but the turn is now
that one MONTH BEFORE , they had an explosion killing the owner himself , totaly destroying the factory.
the place looks quite impressive after explosion of around 80 kg MEKP at once and i am impressed by power of MEKP , more to this , they did their
earliar process in a plastic bath , i am on a way to say them start a new set up in 20 lts glass flask in a salted ice bath ,
specifically invstigating their blast , i have found following :
1_ they did not have any single window open that day :- no ventilation in site : i suggesting high to this
2_ they hurried adding last few MEK to the h2o2 and added 2 kg at once.
3_ operated an electrical switch after 5 mins and kabooom at that time .....no temp known , owner died with the reading in mind and none there that
day.
i am confused and irritated to find out what are the decomposition products of this compound and when does the decomposition happen actually ... one
more thing to say , that they use DEP to 50 % dilute the final product from beginning of reaction
i suspect the explosion not by itself MEKP but the decomposing gases filling the whole area and then a spark from switch operation because until it
there were lights on. witness say that first lights went of in site and then boooomm .
SOMEBODY OUT THERE PLEASE HELP ME , I AM HAVING BIG RESPONCIBILITY AND PROBLEM ON MY SHOULDERS ,
DO HELP A STUDENT IN INDIA ... YOU ALL POSSESS EXPERIMETAL KNOWLEGE OF THIS PRODUCT , SO IF THERE ARE POINTS I MAY BENIFIT FROM , ... DO POST THEM
FREELY
.... THANKS.
|
|
|
DDTea
National Hazard
Posts: 940
Registered: 25-2-2003
Location: Freedomland
Member Is Offline
Mood: Degenerate
|
|
Indeed, some of us do have experimental knowledge with Organic Peroxides, and most of us have come to the conclusion that they are dangerously
unstable...
In computer programming, I know that one of the best ways to study and fix an error is to try to reproduce it. I would suggest the same thing to
you-- try, in lab sized quantities, the addition of MEK to Hydrogen Peroxide. Then, try the RUSHED addition of MEK to H2O2, and look for any
explosive gases.
What is DEP? I looked it up on Chemfinder, and it lists Diethyl Pthalate and Diethyl Pyrocarbonate. I'm thinking it is Diethyl Pthalate. In any
case, the idea is to reproduce the accident, so that you know what to avoid and design equipment to prevent future accidents.
|
|
|
chemoleo
Biochemicus Energeticus
Posts: 3005
Registered: 23-7-2003
Location: England Germany
Member Is Offline
Mood: crystalline
|
|
yes, it is diethylphtalate. This is what it is commonly diluted in, just like my hardener fluid.
Anyway, I would suggest the following for the future:
1. CONTINOUS control of temperature, with emergency measures once temperature goes to high. Such as dumping the whole lot into icecold water. I
believe a number of explosives are manufactured while always having a dumping apparatus present, which can be operated REMOTELY (such as
nitroglycerin).
2. Add any ingredients remotely, to avoid personal exposure in case of trouble
3. Never allow fumes to enter the work area, either work with a lidded system, or if pressure goes up, have a pressure valve that safely disposes and
solvent/MEKP fumes. Bloody hell, similar explosions could happen if you just made acetone, or diethylether, or cracked petrol if you allow fumes to
escape!
4. Although I don't know, I am pretty sure that given enough heat/shock, it would be still possible to detonate the diluted MEKP in the reaction
pot.
5. For decomposition products, look up the formula of MEKP, and once do the calculation of MEKP alone, and once in the presence of oxygen (i.e. in the
MEKP vapour filled room)
6. Being a peroxide, I would avoid metal exposure at all times. Conversely, using a plastic container, make sure it's the non-static variety.
7. Within the reaction vessel, purge the atmosphere with nitrogen, so that no O2 is present that might facilitate vapour explosions.
Also, another test would be to add a small beaker filled with a little MEKP into a closed container (not metal, just a simple plastic
balloon/container type of thing). Then, expose it to the temperatures you normally find at the work place. Leave it for a few hours. Remove the
beaker, seal the balloon/plastic container. I would try and do this remotely. Might be very sensitve, simple static electrical discharge could be
enough to set it off. See if it ignites/explodes upon flame exposure/electrical discharge operated remotely. Shouldnt be a terribly dangerous
explosion if you are a few 10s of meters away. Depends on size of the container though... Well if it explodes, then you know that at least in part
this contributed to the explosion...by the way, I am sure the diethylphtalate is flammable, and evaporates easily. This may have to do with the
air/vapour explosion, too.
Regarding the latter, it's a theoretical suggestion, I certainly wouldn't be up for trying it !!!
Never Stop to Begin, and Never Begin to Stop...
Tolerance is good. But not with the intolerant! (Wilhelm Busch)
|
|
|
vulture
Forum Gatekeeper
Posts: 3330
Registered: 25-5-2002
Location: France
Member Is Offline
Mood: No Mood
|
|
Because of it's very negative oxygen balance, there is a severe risk of secundary explosions, especially in confined space, after the initial
explosion of MEKP.
CO or simple organic molecules like C2H4 could be responsible for that.
Please keep this in mind at all times.
One shouldn't accept or resort to the mutilation of science to appease the mentally impaired.
|
|
|
blazter
Hazard to Self
Posts: 71
Registered: 3-9-2002
Member Is Offline
Mood: No Mood
|
|
even in small quantities be careful
If you intend to do a controlled experiment as Samosa suggested bear in mind the extreme power of this substance when it detonates. Even quantities
as small as 50g have the potential of causing dismemberment if it was to detonate at an bad time. Personally witnessing the detonating of 50g even
under controlled circumstances (at a considerable distance, with protective gear, behind a wall of earth) was enough to give me a whole new respect of
MEKP and high explosives in general.
|
|
|
Hermes_Trismegistus
National Hazard
Posts: 602
Registered: 27-11-2003
Location: Greece, Ancient
Member Is Offline
Mood: conformation:ga
|
|
EXTRA!!! EXTRA!!!! READ ALL ABOUT IT!!! INDIA REDUCES PAKISTAN TO SMOKING CRATER!!!! REVOLUTIONARIES CREDIT "SCIENCE MADNESS FORUM" WITH
VITAL AID! CONGRESS PASSES FASCIST NEW CENSORSHIP LAWS IN RESPONSE!!! EXTRA!!! EXTRA!!!! READ ALL ABOUT IT
FIFTY FRICKING KILOGRAMS!!!! ARE YOU TRYING TO SPLIT THE FRICKING EARTH IN HALF!!!!???!!!
I AM SUPRISED WE DIDN'T HEAR THAT BLAST ALL THE WAY OVER HERE!!!
GAKK!!
ANYWAY, I would suggest that if someone wanted to make such quatities it would be important to use glass to keep dangerous unstable metal compounds
from forming. I would use (and mind you this is a little hard to describe without a drawing) A flow-through system.
Wherein, you connect several, mostly horizontal, slightly tilted, pipes in series in a zig zag pattern so that the product slowly moves down the grid
of pipes with a little bit of peroxide being added, with simple injectors at the "elbows" of the piping, to the "river" of mek as
it travels down the series of pipes.
It seems good to use gravity because of the danger of getting product caught in the pumps.
it is however a matter of good design to figure out the surface area of the piping in relation to the amount of heat generated by the reaction. It
would be important that the heat is dissipated from one length of pipe before the next joint (and H2O2 injector) came up at the next bend and heated
it up even more!
it would also take some thought to figure out the size of the injector needed to add the proper amount of peroxide and the speed of the flow of
product out of the spout at the bottom. It is also wise to add the secondary reactant/s at the elbows in order to take advantage of the mixing action
of the turbulence induced by the joint.
It is also important to know that these setups are often pretty tall.
However the benefit of a flow through system is obvious, feedstock in the top, product formed by the time it exits at the bottom!
P.S. I TAKE NO LEGAL RESPONSIBILITY FOR ANY ACTIONS OF YOU OR ANYONE ELSE!!!
I am speaking in the theoreticalin response to a theoretical postulation!
good luck, don't die!
Arguing on the internet is like running in the special olympics; even if you win: you\'re still retarded.
|
|
|
Hermes_Trismegistus
National Hazard
Posts: 602
Registered: 27-11-2003
Location: Greece, Ancient
Member Is Offline
Mood: conformation:ga
|
|
p.s. use glass pipes
do NOT try to recreate the scene of a fatal accident....YOU MIGHT SUCCEED!!!
Arguing on the internet is like running in the special olympics; even if you win: you\'re still retarded.
|
|
|
unionised
International Hazard
Posts: 5128
Registered: 1-11-2003
Location: UK
Member Is Offline
Mood: No Mood
|
|
A country might decide to make MEKP to use as a military explosive. OTOH they could just buy the stuff
http://www.lanquan.com/products.htm
They offer a price per ton.
I don't think we need to worry about being acused of starting WWIII
[Edited on 24-12-2003 by unionised]
|
|
|
mananvbhatt
Harmless
Posts: 4
Registered: 9-12-2003
Location: ahmedabad , india
Member Is Offline
Mood: confused , furi
|
|
thanks
such good responce from you all ,
thanks lot ,
friends , one prson says .. 50 kgs... you wanna split the earth !! true man ,
if i describe the scene , there are 3 partners in this firm , one was out another gon for a tea in near canteen , and this fellow quarralled with
labourers and make them out ..DECIDING WHOLE PRODUCTION ON HIS OWN HAND .. you know , the kaboom was heard in the whole district man.. and the walls
of even the 5th most factory with rcc are found twisted like "s" no other signs of any thing in factory ... but i am confused about :-
how might have been the explosion initiated .. i tried the false lab setup as one suggested ... in a such small quantity .. but nothing particularly
happened ...
i am really suspicious that decomposition of mekp caused hydrocarbons to get off , yhey filled the room , and then as they are no smell full gases ,
when switch operated , explosion was initiated , .. witnesses say that there were 3 explosions heard one by one , and it fits as 3 were the reaction
vessels .. each having around 15-16 kg mekp formed in it ...
help me find the chemistry and products of decomposition particularly , i am supposed to give a bottom limit .. in deg centigrade ... which is
irreversible to control mekp from decomposing ...
again thanks for your obviously sincere help ... you all..
|
|
|
mananvbhatt
Harmless
Posts: 4
Registered: 9-12-2003
Location: ahmedabad , india
Member Is Offline
Mood: confused , furi
|
|
one more thing
what i intended is this people make it since 4 yrs . they never allow temp go up 25 even , they are not fools , but they don't know mekp and
chemical behaviour , i doubt more on gases as witnesses first describe a power failure at site and some seconds after fire , followed by 3 explosions
, thats why i am keen on decomposition
by the way dep is dietyl phthalate and used to supress explosive nature.
|
|
|
Iv4
Hazard to Others
Posts: 312
Registered: 28-5-2003
Member Is Offline
Mood: No Mood
|
|
I dont mean to be rude but I'm a little skepticl man,I'm in new delhi ATM but it hant gone above 25 in the last month ,j/k
My personal experiance with MEKP is less than 300 grams but I can strongly recomend you pick something else:it's weak,it stinks,it disoves
many/most common containers,etc
Since your not setting up a 2Kt/day factory I'd sugest this be done semi maunaly.For example have a reaction vessel with pipes a good distance
way for safety and pour the precurses down the pipe(seperate pipes ofcourse).
Some cooling like even AL pipes with cold water running through them is probably a good idea.
On a theretical note how's about passing singelt/delta oxygen into the mix?I'm not recomending this but just askign everyone.
Final conclusion= MEKP sucks donkey nuts.
Edit:
This is'nt a scientific thought but I think it's possible that some MEKP got stuck on the sides of a container or got spiled or
something.Heh maybe someone was having a smoke,either way I cant really think of anything more than human error.
Hapens to the best of us(hint,large N2 laser+ APAL = bad)
[Edited on 29-12-2003 by Iv4]
|
|
|
blazter
Hazard to Self
Posts: 71
Registered: 3-9-2002
Member Is Offline
Mood: No Mood
|
|
some ideas
You mention that the reaction was carried out in a plastic container, it is possible that the mix got hot enough to either dissolve or melt through
it. This could've caused the MEKP to spill out, possibly finding an ignition source.
Another consideration is that if the temperature was higher than normal for this failed batch is that the MEKP could've evaporated or boiled on
its own. MEKP has a very distinctive odor, which is very noticible even when it is kept rather cool. It is possible that the MEKP vapors found a
source of ignition... the switch as you suggest. These vapors would likely be very unpleasant in a closed room, and could possibly have caused the
operators to become unconscious.
The exact conditions of the accident may be difficult if not impossible to reproduce because of the large volumes of reactants which were used. It is
possible that the reaction incurred a "runaway" condition where the heat evolved continued to rise as the reaction proceded faster.
As for a definite temperate where MEKP spontaneously ignites/detonates, that may be difficult to determine. Since organic peroxides like MEKP tend to
be very unstable, they have a tendency to explode for no particular reason. Naturally the probability for explosion will be higher as the temperature
increases, but this does not necessarily mean there is a set "ignition temperature". The conditions where the MEKP will explode will be
based on probability, the probability of enough molecules of MEKP spontaneously decomposing to start a chain reaction.
A way to get some practical knowledge of this would be to gradually heat a very small sample of MEKP until it burns or explodes. This is a fairly
hazardous undertaking, and all possible safety measures should be taken. The sample size should be no larger than a single drop. Another thing this
heating test will show is if any signifant quanty of vapors are produced.
|
|
|
Polverone
Now celebrating 21 years of madness
Posts: 3186
Registered: 19-5-2002
Location: The Sunny Pacific Northwest
Member Is Offline
Mood: Waiting for spring
|
|
keep flaming private
Send IgnorantlyIntelligent U2U messages, e-mail, bricks through his windows, etc. But don't clutter up the forum with flaming, even though the
post you're responding to is also clutter.
Also, please refrain from all-caps postings. The WWW is not Telegraph 2.0. In fact, I didn't make it all the way through your flame because it
was in all caps and poorly formatted in general. There's no excuse for writing hard-to-read messages, even when you're yelling.
|
|
|
guaguanco
Hazard to Others
Posts: 216
Registered: 26-11-2003
Member Is Offline
Mood: heterocyclic
|
|
| Quote: | Originally posted by mananvbhatt
friends , i am from india ,
a student at final year project ,
here at the hot climate of around 42-45 people wanna manufacture MEKP at small capacity and in
small scale industry setup.
i need your help at the point that i have been asigned the project to suggest , implement and commission a small plant for manufacturing this damn
bastard explosive at this much hot climate . |
Sorry, this doesn't pass my smell test.
Its like saying:
"Hi, I've been the assigned the task of setting up a TNT factory, so I'm going to look around on little bulletin boards to tell me how
to do it." (No offense to anyone here; worthy amateur chemists all).
Either you have the expertise to properly research this highly technical, highly specialized, highly dangerous enterprise or you don't. The fact
that you're even asking here (again, no offense anybody) indicates that you don't. Cut your losses and get another project.
IMHO
|
|
|
mfilip62
pierced by a crossbow under a bridge while eating Billy goats
Posts: 140
Registered: 25-8-2006
Member Is Offline
Mood: I like turtles!
|
|
I hearded on news many times about stupid gypsy from India
blowing themselwes and whole streats up while doing something with explosives! 
Are there in Idnia any explosive regulations adn laws!?
Please,I want help you,soo please listen me!
If you realy have friends who are willing to help you,
DO NOT MAKE primary explosives,specialy peroxydes in such great quantity!!!
Eweryrhing ower 80g of AP or MEKP is extremly lethal!!!
Make some PETN,TNP,AN... or binaryes like AN+NM,AN+Ethylene diamine(PLX),ANFO...
If you really have team make some AN from fertilyzer,
ith is ideal "team"explosive becouse it requires a lot of
work when it is manufactured in great quantity!
("cooking",filtering,drying,drying and more drying)
belive me,it has wery big potential and deacent power!
half kg of ANFO can completly destroy a car!
|
|
|
Marsh
Hazard to Self
Posts: 79
Registered: 28-7-2006
Member Is Offline
Mood: No Mood
|
|
| Quote: | Originally posted by mfilip62
I hearded on news many times about stupid gypsy from India
blowing themselwes and whole streats up while doing something with explosives!
Are there in Idnia any explosive regulations adn laws!?
Please,I want help you,soo please listen me!
If you realy have friends who are willing to help you,
DO NOT MAKE primary explosives,specialy peroxydes in such great quantity!!!
Eweryrhing ower 80g of AP or MEKP is extremly lethal!!!
Make some PETN,TNP,AN... or binaryes like AN+NM,AN+Ethylene diamine(PLX),ANFO...
If you really have team make some AN from fertilyzer,
ith is ideal "team"explosive becouse it requires a lot of
work when it is manufactured in great quantity!
("cooking",filtering,drying,drying and more drying)
belive me,it has wery big potential and deacent power!
half kg of ANFO can completly destroy a car! |
I'm surprised you brought this back up...it is from 2003. Makes you wonder what ever happened with this "operation", eh?
But while you gave me some things to post about, I'll take the chance.
I wonder if this topic was originally started with intentions for explosive use, or for use as curing agents (either or, obviously working at this
place...ah hem...might be a little scary).
Personally, and not to give new reading amateurs the 'go ahead', I have to say I myself feel MEKP is a fairly safe peroxide when treated as a
peroxide, although definitely not in the quantities discussed above (80kg  , I
cannot fathom what occurred that day...) It is liquid of coarse and stirring 150ml final product, I am not nearly as shaky and sweaty as I am while
scraping just 10g of TCAP from a plate when dry. If you are going to attempt any peroxide over 20g (or 10g for that matter), please make it MEKP over
TCAP anyday. The only reason I really still mess with MEKP is its obvious ease-of-production and emersive properties with potent oxidizers, and for
those seeking; ease of initiation.
But what exactly are you meaning when you say "AN from fertilizer"? Are you saying actual production of ammonium nitrate solely, or preparing the
coated prill type?
And not to argue, as you are just trying to make a point, but I don't think 1/2kg ANFO would "completely destroy" a car (in it or under it, although
the interior might be fairly mangled). 1Kg+ may start to get interesting, though .
(Sorry to add more to such an old thread, I'm sure the mods just love seeing this first post "huge quantity India manufacture MEKP" reappear in 2006
 )
[Edited on 26-8-2006 by Marsh]
|
|
|
quicksilver
International Hazard
Posts: 1820
Registered: 7-9-2005
Location: Inches from the keyboard....
Member Is Offline
Mood: ~-=SWINGS=-~
|
|
| Quote: |
Sorry, this doesn't pass my smell test.
Its like saying:
"Hi, I've been the assigned the task of setting up a TNT factory, so I'm going to look around on little bulletin boards to tell me how to do it." (No
offense to anyone here; worthy amateur chemists all).
Either you have the expertise to properly research this highly technical, highly specialized, highly dangerous enterprise or you don't. The fact that
you're even asking here (again, no offense anybody) indicates that you don't. Cut your losses and get another project.
IMHO |
I not only strongly agree but I am suprised that this thread has moved along to such a degree.... Come on.... peroxides? That is not a commercial
energetic material and has not been thought of in that sense through most of the last century. Something is quite wrong with any commercial firm
working on "commercial" (read - kitchen made) energetic materials that would allow such a thing to take place - let alone lack the background research
to prevent it. This thing screams bullsh*t . That a commercial concern overlooks or mishandles the simple temp comtrol of a reaction are not
believable; period.
NO, I don't buy this thing at all. I think this thread should be left alone. What has been said should be enough to satisfy the "commercial concerns"
of such a "company".
Totse is easy to find.....
[Edited on 26-8-2006 by quicksilver]
|
|
|
Marsh
Hazard to Self
Posts: 79
Registered: 28-7-2006
Member Is Offline
Mood: No Mood
|
|
| Quote: | Originally posted by quicksilver
I think this thread should be left alone. What has been said should be enough to satisfy the "commercial concerns" of such a "company".
Totse is easy to find.....
|
Again like I said, it's from 2003. I think the main reason it was brought back up was to make fun of the post. Obviously the man who started it is not
around anymore (here, and possibly elseware)...
But for the concerns of the forum, I think moderators should outright delete threads like these which generate such nasty outlook from outside
sources.
[Edited on 26-8-2006 by Marsh]
|
|
|
mfilip62
pierced by a crossbow under a bridge while eating Billy goats
Posts: 140
Registered: 25-8-2006
Member Is Offline
Mood: I like turtles!
|
|
I am "making" pure amonium nitrate(chrystal) from KAN(kalcijev amonijev nitrat)!
Ith is Croatian prill tipe fertilizer maded from amonium ntrate and CaO and MgO(actually CaCO3 and MgCO3).
What you need to do is joust simple dilution,filtration and dehyration!
Only main problem is that you moust do that during summertime,when it is wery hot,becouse AN need to be absolutely dry.
It sounds and is quite simple,but it requires a lot or hard work.
Balive or not this chrystal tipe AN(FO) is quite powerfull,
Fiat 500 was totaly demolished,engine flit over pine wood,there was a big holl on the floor,and roof disappeared!
I used PETN and TNP as a booster, comercial No.8 det.cap, 60m of wire, 9V and Christmas tree electric bulb filled with black powder as igniter!
|
|
|
mananvbhatt
Harmless
Posts: 4
Registered: 9-12-2003
Location: ahmedabad , india
Member Is Offline
Mood: confused , furi
|
|
thanks for al the posts up here, i declare the post closed from my side,
the place is up , running , between the dates of my first and last post on this thread , there has been nothing gone wrong, and we have been
successful managing the facility.
thx.
specially to guaguanco
|
|
|
Marsh
Hazard to Self
Posts: 79
Registered: 28-7-2006
Member Is Offline
Mood: No Mood
|
|
| Quote: | Originally posted by mananvbhatt
thanks for al the posts up here, i declare the post closed from my side,
the place is up , running , between the dates of my first and last post on this thread , there has been nothing gone wrong, and we have been
successful managing the facility.
thx.
specially to guaguanco |
Could you post photos of your operation?
I would love to see how you have managed to successfully setup your facility, as well as some of the manufacturing techniques you are using to
continue this in a safe way with no accidents.
Also, how is such large quantity of final product being used?
[Edited on 27-8-2006 by Marsh]
|
|
|
|
![[*]](images/xpblue/default_icon.gif){kind=icon}
