Sciencemadness Discussion Board

mystery reaction (at least for me)

SimpleChemist-238 - 3-5-2015 at 08:29

Last night I got around to purifying the ASA I bought at the dollar store and began by stirring and boiling. After 20 min of that I filtered using paper towels and let the solution sit for a hour. The translucent needle crystals showed there face and I collected them and stored them in a container made of ABS.

Later that day I wanted to see if I could make yellow chloro-ASA by using 2g of ASA, 50ml of bleach solution (Household) and 1ml of HCl (30%).

I let the reaction mixture do its thing for 12 hours with strong stirring. I awoke the next day to a deep red solution of my mystery compound. Any idea what it is?

Texium - 3-5-2015 at 08:55

Well, I don't know exactly what happened there, but the "needle crystals" that you describe sound a lot more like salicylic acid than ASA, which forms plate-like crystals. Did you boil it in water? If so, that could have caused it to hydrolyze. Did you notice any scent of acetic acid while you were boiling it?
Usually, I grind up the tablets and soak them in warm isopropanol, filter, and then let that evaporate. It's slow, but the ASA you get from it is much more pure.

Fantasma4500 - 3-5-2015 at 09:11

heating salicylic acid will turn it into phenol and partially into phenol-salicylic ''stuff'' too, which has a much higher melting point and is brown-reddish
i dont know if heating ASA could turn it into phenol too, but phenol has a very deep smell like charred wood
IF ASA doesnt turn into smelly compounds when heated abit this could be a rather simple test

SimpleChemist-238 - 3-5-2015 at 10:24

I don't think its SA because I know AS and its not what I got at the end of the extraction. I used 150ml of iso alchl to extract the ASA. There is no way it decarboxilated in my knowledge of its property's. Maybe it reacted with the sodium hypochlorite? What color is chloro ASA?

aga - 3-5-2015 at 10:45

Could someone please say what ASA is ?

Acetyl salicylic acid ?

This beginnings, and as beginner, i confused.

Edit :

Changd it make me sound les of an inglish spoker.

[Edited on 3-5-2015 by aga]

szuko03 - 3-5-2015 at 11:12

It's aspirin by common name (99.9% sure)

aga - 3-5-2015 at 11:19

OK. ASA is Aspirin.

So it is acetylsalycilic acid.

Thanks, less confused now.

Volanschemia - 3-5-2015 at 17:03

Haha, don't worry aga, I hate acronyms for compound names as well.

IrC - 3-5-2015 at 21:27

Proper procedure when one begins a thread immediately tossing acronyms into the mix should be at least define them once. It can be understood no one wishes to write acetylsalycilic acid a dozen times and in cases like this the first use ought to be acetylsalycilic acid (ASA), or even Aspirin (ASA) in this case is acceptable. From then on ASA would be immediately known and spare ten thousand visitors each having to do a web search because they did not wish to appear ignorant and ask. In my opinion this is poor posting to assume everyone knows or should know what you meant by the acronym. If one considers millions of possible organic chemicals alone there could be many which fit the identical acronym and over time these things along with the language itself change. Why create confusion?

aga - 4-5-2015 at 12:24

Quote: Originally posted by IrC  
they did not wish to appear ignorant and ask.

In my state, i do not care if i appear ignorant when i am in fact ingnorant.

Thankfully the answer was given, augmenting my norance of the genre.

IrC - 4-5-2015 at 14:09

Many however, especially younger, still worry about 'status' and do not ask. It saves many from searching if a procedure of giving explanation when each acronym is first introduced in a thread. Also saves confusion and possibly mistakes, especially important in chemistry. As an exaggerated example say someone here posts a thread on making Cinnamon suckers. Later we learn some 14 year old read CO and expired bubbling monoxide in the syrup instead of adding Cinnamon Oil. I know, ridiculous example but it makes the point. Explaining acronyms when introduced should be proper conduct for all threads. Just my opinion but there it is.

blogfast25 - 4-5-2015 at 14:37

Quote: Originally posted by IrC  
Explaining acronyms when introduced should be proper conduct for all threads.


Or call it 'MindreadersMadness'...