Sciencemadness Discussion Board

Hygroscopy vs. purity

dangerous amateur - 15-11-2012 at 05:07

Hi,

can you explain, why hygroscopy in certain chemicals, especially salts, seems to depend on their purity grade?


ScienceSquirrel - 15-11-2012 at 05:53

In the case of sodium chloride, very pure sea salt is only slightly hygroscopic. I have some from the Carmargue that is pure white and free running but I also have some sel gris 'grey salt' from Guérande and that is always slightly damp like moist sand. It is also slightly bitter and more salt tasting and I think this is due to things like magnesium and potassium salts, some of which may be more hygroscopic than sodium chloride.

dangerous amateur - 29-11-2012 at 05:27

Yes, there can be contaminations that are more hygroscopic. But can it be that hygroscopy is affected by the simple fact that several different salts are mixed?


unionised - 29-11-2012 at 12:51

Yes.
It's possible for a pair of non reacting, non hygroscopic salts to make a mixture that is hygroscopic.
A salt will be hygroscopic if the vapour pressure of water above a saturated solution is higher then the vapour pressure of water in the air. (so, whether or not something is hygroscopic depends on the ambient humidity)
Adding another salt will reduce the vapour pressure of water above the solution so the amount of water in the air needed to make the mixture hygroscopic will be smaller.
So the mixture will be hygroscopic at lower humidities than either of the salts it's made from.
If that change brings the cut-off below the ambient humidity then the mixture will be hygroscopic, even if the components aren't.

On a practical basis a mixture of salt and sugar is a lot more hygroscopic than either component.

woelen - 29-11-2012 at 23:22

Another nice example of a mix which is very hygroscopic while its constituents are not is KNO3 + NH4ClO4. KNO3 is not hygroscopic at all. NH4ClO4 is very weakly hygroscopic. When these chemicals are mixed as fine powder, then the mix attracts water easily, due to formation of NH4NO3, which is very hygroscopic.