Sciencemadness Discussion Board

Copper cyanurate (and other cyanurates}

Lion850 - 19-6-2020 at 20:00

** There are many threads on copper cyanurate on Sciencemadness, for example:

http://www.sciencemadness.org/talk/viewthread.php?tid=155534...
http://www.sciencemadness.org/talk/viewthread.php?tid=29474#...
http://www.sciencemadness.org/talk/viewthread.php?tid=73900#...

But as far as I could see all involve the chlorinated compound while I wanted to try and make the 'basic' (for lack of a better word) cyanuric acid salt. Thus I started a new thread.

I previously made the well known purple compound copper-sodium-dichloroisocyanurate but I was keen to try and make copper cyanurate. Wikipedia says copper cyanurate forms in swimming pools when cyanuric acid reacts with high levels of copper, and shows a purple product.

I wanted to make copper cyanurate using only OTC materials. I had cyanuric acid and copper sulphate (from pool or hardware shops), sodium hydroxide (from a local department store), and copper carbonate that I made a long time ago from copper sulphate and sodium hydroxide. See photo.

A few months ago I tried to react a cyanuric acid solution with both copper sulphate and copper nitrate and that did not seem to do anything. So this time I decided to react copper carbonate with cyanuric acid:

CuCO3 + C3N3H3O3 = C3HCuN3O3 + H2O + CO2

- 11g cyanuric acid was added to 300ml water, stirred and heated. It seems quite insoluble until the solubility suddenly seems to increase at the water boiling point and the solution then clears up.
- Slowly add 10g of copper carbonate, stirring all the time (to crudely check if my old carbonate still behaves as a carbonate i earlier added some to a bit of concentrated HCl - it bubbled vigorously and all quickly dissolved into a green solution so seemed more or less good).
- A sea green suspension resulted with some foamy bubbles, which I presume was CO2. See photo.
- After 4 hours of stirring and keeping it warm the solution was grey, with a hint of purple which is hard to see on a photo. There was no more bubbles, and no smell. I stopped the stirring and grey ppt settled out. See photo. I started the stirring again and left it going overnight, but it looked the same the next morning.
- The solution was filtered. The filtrate was clear. The grey remainder was washed a few times with water in the filter.
- The clear filtrate was tested with sodium hydroxide, there was no ppt or cloudiness but just a very slight gold tinge; as I saw later this is often observed when NaOH is added to cyanuric acid so my filtrate probably had a slight excess of cyanuric acid dissolved and no copper salts. Which was good.
- The grey remainder was dried on a steam bath. The predominantly grey color became slightly lighter towards very pale purple. See photo.
- Final recovery of dry powder was 18g. The target from the above formula was 16g, so it is either not 100% dry (although it appears very dry and free flowing) or it is a hydrate.

So, if this is copper cyanurate, why is it not a more pronounced purple color? I could not find another description of copper cyanurate anywhere. I saw link to reports on studies of cyanuric acid reactions with metals, but they are not freely accessible. In swimming pools, when "copper cyanurate" is said to form, there is of course always also sodium and chlorine present and I wondered if the presence of these are needed to get the purple compound. This then lead to the next experiment which I will detail in the next post.

Comments from anyone with knowledge about copper cyanurate will be greatly appreciated.



1 Raw materials.jpg - 733kB 2 Copper carbonate in cyanuric acid.jpg - 708kB 3 CuCO3 reacting and going grey pale purple.jpg - 762kB 4 Copper cyanurate (maybe) drying.jpg - 466kB

[Edit: title changed at request of OP.]

[Edited on 10-7-2020 by j_sum1]

Lion850 - 19-6-2020 at 20:59

Part 2.
The next step following from the above was to add sodium to the reaction to see if I get a purple compound. I did quite a few trial runs with various results. Eventually the below ratios and method gave consistantly a similarly looking product.

The first step was to make sodium cyanurate in solution:

NaOH + C3N3H3O3 = C3H2N3NaO3 + H2O

- 16.5g of cuanuric acid was added to 450ml water, stir and heat.
- At boiling the solution just about cleared up, still slightly cloudy.
- Add 4g solid sodium hydroxide while stirring and keeping hot.
** These quantities was to allow for the cyanuric acid possible being a hydrate - if dehydrated, the acid is in excess. Important not to have the sodium hydroxide in excess as this then yields unwanted copper hydroxide during the next part.
- As the NaOH is added the solution cleared up and again the very slight golden tinge was seen.
- After 20 minutes of stirring the solution turns white due to a suspension. I assume this is sodium cyanurate, whith low solubility in hot (bit not near boiling) water?
- Stirring was continued for a total of one hour. pH was checked with my swimming pool test kit and found to be 8.
* This should have given some 15g of sodium cyanurate in solution (or rather suspension)

Next step was to add copper sulphate. But, I could not find a formula for copper-sodium-cyanurate (without the chloride) anywhere. The below equation was one of a few that my app would allow, but the one which seems to best fit the amounts of reactants used and product yield:

2C3H2N3NaO3 + CuSO4 = Cu(C3N3NaO3)2 + H2SO4 + H2 ???

- 6g CuSO4.5H2O was added. The solution immediately turned purple. See photo. There seemed a bit of fizz for a few seconds but whether this was hydrogen as per the formula I do not know. After 15 minutes stirring was stopped. A purple ppt settled, and the supernatant solution was very pale blue. Another 2g of CuSO4.5H2O was added abd stirred for an hour, the supernatant solution was now more strongly blue indicating that copper sulphate was now in excess. See photo.
- Vacuum filter. The filtrate was slightly blue, and the remainder purple.
- Wash a few times in the filter with room temperature water, until run-through is clear.
** The first time I tried to wash with boiling water, as I knew sodium cyanurate and cyanuric acid is much more soluble in boiling water. But the very top layer of the purple compound turned green when in contact with the boiling water, plus the purple compound itself becomes soluble at boiling point! See photo. I will investigate the formation of this green compound further.
- Dry the remainder on the steam bath for hours until the weight stabilised. See photo. The color slightly lightened as it dried.
- Final recovery was 15.1g of the fine dry light-purple powder. The color is a bit lighter than the better known copper-sodium-dichloroisocyanurate. See photo of the 3 products together: the (suspected) copper cyanurate, the copper-sodium-cyanurate, and the copper-sodium-dichlorocyanurate.

So I got the purple color I was after, but a lot of assumptions and guessing what is actually going on. Please comment and correct as required! Links to relevant literature will also be appreciated as I found very little.

5 Adding CuSO4 to sodium cyanurate suspension.jpg - 544kB 6 Purple ppt, CuSO4 in excess.jpg - 762kB 7 Purple ppt turnrs green with boiling water and becomes soluble.jpg - 461kB 8 After second rinse with cold water, clear run through.jpg - 429kB 9 Copper sodium cyanurate drying.jpg - 470kB 10 Final products with previous dichloro cyanurate for comparison.jpg - 564kB

j_sum1 - 19-6-2020 at 21:12

My understanding is that the purple is a complex involving the NaDCCA salt. This indeed does form in swimming pools and is probably what is being described.
I don't know anything about the copper cyanurate product you are after. But with the inclusion of HCl in your first procedure it is easy to imagine you getting a mixture that includes a purple substance and appears grey as a consequence.

Bedlasky - 19-6-2020 at 23:31

Nice looking product.

This isn't redox reaction, so there isn't any hydrogen formation.

[Edited on 20-6-2020 by Bedlasky]

Lion850 - 20-6-2020 at 00:21

Quote: Originally posted by j_sum1  
My understanding is that the purple is a complex involving the NaDCCA salt. This indeed does form in swimming pools and is probably what is being described.
I don't know anything about the copper cyanurate product you are after. But with the inclusion of HCl in your first procedure it is easy to imagine you getting a mixture that includes a purple substance and appears grey as a consequence.


Hi J_sum1 I think I was not clear. In the first procedure there was only cyanuric acid and copper carbonate. HCl was only involved to crudely test the old copper carbonate and give me some assurance it is indeed a carbonate prior to using it :)

Lion850 - 20-6-2020 at 04:14


I found a review "Cyanuric Acid and Cyanurates" by G. B. Seifer online, I try to link it below:

Attachment: Cyanuric Acid and Cyanurates GB Seifer.pdf (335kB)
This file has been downloaded 610 times

Seems there are many different types of cyanurates formed and also various hydrates with different colors. See Table 1 on page 10 of the attached file. A few more things to try!

Bezaleel - 23-6-2020 at 15:54

This is a really awesome review article. It greatly helped me understand what went on when I was not able to produce the purple copper complex, when I experimented with it in 2014.

Many who have experimented with TCA have not realised that somewhere in their process they lost some or all of the chlorine and were left with copper cyanurate, instead of copper chlorocyanurate as they expected. Since I expected this, and wished to rule out one source of uncertainty, I worked with cyanuric acid (or its sodium or potassium salt), which I obtained by dissolving TCA in HCl solution. The white precipitate formed is cyanuric acid. (TCA + HCl (aq) --> CYA + Cl2)

woelen - 24-6-2020 at 01:28

Very interesting result. So, it is clear that cyanuric acid can give a purple compound.

The reaction probably is very simple. Let's write the acid as H3X (with X being the remainder of the cyanuric acid molecule, containing C, N, O). Then on addition of sufficient NaOH, you get Na3X in solution. It can also be that you get Na2HX or NaH2X in solution. As cyanuric acid is a very weak acid, I expect one of the latter, a good candidate will be Na2HX.

With copper you then get CuHX: Cu(2+) + HX(2-) --> CuHX

No involvement of H2, no generation of H2SO4. Just a very simple precipitation reaction.
________________________________________________

It is interesting to investigate behavior at different pH-values. I doubt that you can get Cu3X2, most likely the ion X(3-) is too basic to allow this. This is very much like that CuCO3 cannot be obtained, because CO3(2-) is too basic. You get a basic carbonate. Maybe at very high pH you get a basic cyanurate.

So, I think there are multiple possible precipitates:

CuHX
Cu2(OH)X (the basic cyanurate)
Cu(H2X)2 ??

The different precipitates may have different colors. One of them is the bright purple compound, but there are others. A similar effect exists for silver orthoperiodate. Orthoperiodic acid has 5 hydrogen atom, which can be split off, but in practice only the first two or three are split off, except at very high pH. There are multiple silver orthoperiodates, with varying amounts of silver and hydrogen, e.g. Ag2H3IO6 and Ag3H2IO6. They have different colors. Maybe such a phenomenon also exists for copper cyanurates. A lot to be investigated, and this set of experiments is a first step in that direction.

It is best to do this research with true cyanuric acid and not with TCCA or DCCA. These contain chlorine and it is hard to get completely rid of that. Maybe bezaleels method of adding TCCA to HCl and recrystallizing the cyanuric acid two times from boiling water leads to formation of the pure acid. The pure acid is not easy to find OTC (at least not where I live), but I must admit, that I did not search very hard for that. At the regular hardware stores and swimming pool shops it is all TCCA and Na-DCCA.

[Edited on 24-6-20 by woelen]

Lion850 - 24-6-2020 at 02:27

Woelen thanks for your comments. If you look at the document I reference in a previous post it is clear just how many different salts with colors also dependent on hydration can be formed!
According to the msds the pool stabiliser that I use, the hy-clor product in the photo attached to my original post is 100% isocyanuric acid (which as far as I can gather is aka as cyanuric acid). But I don’t know the purity and I don’t know whether it is the dihydrate or anhydrous. I emailed the supplier to ask but no reply yet. I guess I can dissolve in water and recrystalize and then it will for sure be the dihydrate.
A lot more I want to do with this but no time to go to the shed the last few days!

woelen - 24-6-2020 at 23:06

Isocyanuric acid is the same as cyanuric acid (a tautomer, but in solution they are equivalent).
Recrystallization from boiling water is possible. The acid dissolves quite well in hot water, but hardly in cold water.

Boffis - 25-6-2020 at 00:07

Woelen is correct about cyanuric acid. I looked it up in one of my old chemistry books dedicated to cyanogen chemistry. Undr normal circumstances the sodium salt is the mono salt ie NaH2C3N3O3 and the practically insoluble calcium salt Ca(H2C3N3O3)2. The di-sodium salt only crystallises from very concentrated NaOH solutions (it doesn't say how concentrated!) and when recrystallised from water it disproportionates into the mono sodium salt and NaOH solution. Even the first H+ is only weakly acidic, pKa value from wikipedia is given as 6.88 so weaker than acetic acid for the first hydrogen.

Recrystallising cyanuric acid requires about 25ml of boiling water per gram, more if you want to filter it hot.

Lion850 - 25-6-2020 at 02:27

Hi Boffis great info and what I see in the lab starts to make sense. Does your old book perhaps tell you if the hydrated cyanuric acid loses the water when heated (before decomposition) and at what temperature?
Any mention of a grey copper and cyanuric acid salt? I got a grey looking but with very slight purple shade when I reacted copper carbonate (or probably a mix of copper carbonates) with cyanuric acid. Still to be investigated further.

Boffis - 25-6-2020 at 04:54

@Lion850; Cyanuric crystallises from water in anhydrous crystals, any water present means that it is simply not dry yet. William's book on the chemistry of cyanogen compounds mentions several copper salts but unfortunately doesn't give any colour for the simple cyanurate Cu(H2C3N3O3)2 and CuHC3N3O3. The later is prepared from copper salts and sodium cyanurate and the former by magnesium cyanurate on copper salt solutions. You should get a copy of the book, I am pretty sure you can download it from the web, you want the 2nd edition 1948. Great book full of useful info.

Various amino copper salts are described as deep blue, violet and amethyst their preps are referenced. If you can't find a copy online I scan some of my copy.

Lion850 - 4-7-2020 at 21:52

In my original posts up above I mentioned that at one point when I tried to wash the purple sodium copper complex with boiling water it formed a layer of green. I investigated this further and after trying various things I was able to get the purple to green change again:
- 4.5g of purple sodium copper complex was added to approximately 250ml water in a beaker and stirred and heated, giving a purple colored solution/suspension mix. See photo.
- As this was vigorously boiled the color changed to grey. See photo (interestingly, if boiling is continued it becomes purple again at a low water volume).
- The contents was transferred to a large beaker and water added to a total of approximately 500ml and boiled and the color changed to green! See photo.
- The solution was vacuum filtered while still hot. The filtrate was completely clear, and the remainder was green, see photo.
- The filtrate was later boiled down and then cooled, and gave white crystals. See photo.

So it seems the sodium copper complex breaks up when boiled in a large excess of water. I am not sure what the green copper remainder is; it is not copper carbonate as there is no bubbling with HCl. It dissolves into a yellowish solution with concentrated HCl which becomes green when the HCl is diluted.

Also to mention that on my stirring hotplate, which boils large volume solutions much less vigorously, I did not yet see this "break-up" happening. So far, only on my cooking hotplate which is much more powerful.



21 Sodium copper cyanurate complex 5g in 250ml water.jpg - 447kB 22 vigorous boiling and turns grey.jpg - 473kB 23 Extra water and boiling and turns green.jpg - 463kB 24 copper compound after filtering.jpg - 594kB 25 clear filtrate boiled down gives white crystals.jpg - 583kB

Boffis - 5-7-2020 at 01:23

I suspect that on boiling with water the violet complex decomposes giving a ppt of some basic copper salt and a solution of sodium cyanurate or free cyanuric acid, hence the colourless crystals at the end. It would be interesting to know what the anion is in the green material since copper hydroxide would have turned black (CuO).

Diachrynic - 5-7-2020 at 14:43

The purple compound, the "copper-sodium-cyanurate", in the second post is something I have prepared as well, the literature says it is a complex salt of four monodeprotonated cyanurates, one central copper and two sodium ions as counter ions: Na2[Cu(C3H2N3O3)4] This matches 1:1 the complex with NaDCCA by the way, which has the formula Na2[Cu(C3N3O3Cl2)4]

The write-up (in German) can be found here, you can also prepare three ammonia derivatives of copper cyanurate, a di-, tri- and tetraammine compound: https://illumina-chemie.de/viewtopic.php?p=76471

Werner says in his paper that the coordination happens over the deprotonated nitrogens to the copper center.


Here is the tetrakiscyanurate (left) and tetrakisdichloroisocyanurate (right) next to each other:
1433_8666020835e7ca4506ea71.jpg - 311kB

Lion850 - 7-7-2020 at 03:55

@Boffis - I managed to download the book but unfortunately only the first edition - still looking for a place to download the second edition that does not want my credit card details.

Over the last week or so I reacted cyanuric acid with fine copper powder and finally got a lovely deep purple compound:
- 5.1g copper powder, 6g cyanuric acid, and 70ml water added to a small beaker (cyanuric acid in excess).
- Stirred with magnetic stirrer. Heated to near boiling once to dissolve the cyanuric acid and heat then switched off.
- Solution was initially copper colored due to the suspended copper powder
- After 24 hours still the same and I was just about to stop but then saw it was slightly less copper colored. Started to heat the beaker to around 50 degrees. Still some copper visible when stirring stopped.
- After 48 hours the copper color was much faded and it appeared to be heading to white-grey. Still copper present.
- After 72 hours it was starting to look purple. Mo more copper to be seen.
- Once it started to become purple the change was faster and after some 84 hours it was deep purple.
- After 96 hours the color was still the same deep purple and the stirring was stopped (4 days!)
- The solution was vacuum filtered. The filtrate was clear and the remainder a dark purple. The remainder was washed in the filter with excess water.
- A few gram of the remainder was dried on a steam bath to see if the color changed - it did not, and all was then dried on the steam bath.
- Final product was 10.6g of dark purple color.

The document I referenced and linked higher up "Cyanuric Acid and Cyanurates by GB Seifer" mentions only 2 salts for copper reacting on its own with cyanuric acid: a trisubstituted salt Cu3C3N3O3.xH2O or a basic salt (CuOH)H2C3N3O3.2H2O; I do not know which one I ended up with but I am happy I managed to get a purple copper cyanurate without any other metals included), which was the original target.

Below photos shows the color change from copper to dark purple and the final dried product.





30 Cu powder suspension with cyanuric acid.jpg - 667kB 32 color going white-grey.jpg - 750kB 33 color becoming purple.jpg - 540kB 34 color more purple.jpg - 734kB 35 final dark purple color.jpg - 380kB 36 dried remainder 10.6g.jpg - 476kB

Lion850 - 10-7-2020 at 00:47

Manganese:
I had a go at reacting manganese powder with cyanuric acid. According to "Cyanuric Acid and Cyanurates by GB Seifer" linked in an post higher up, manganese on its own forms either the disubstituted salt Mn2HC3N3O3 · xH2O or a basic salt (MnOH)H2C3N3O3 · 2H2O. I mixed 5.4g manganese powder and 8.6g cyanuric acid which puts the acid in slight excess assuming 1) the acid is the dihidrate and 2) the disubstituted salt will form. 90g water was added and the lot was stirred with moderate heat.
There seem to be an immediate reaction with small bubbles, and after some 12 hours no more manganese powder could be seen and the solution was a pale peach color. Stirring was continued for another 30 hours or so but there was no further color change. To note though was that the mixture became a bit like a slurry, quite thick.
The solution was filtered; the remainder was very fine and a light tan color. It was dried on the steam bath until the weight was stable; this took quite a while.

Final product was 13.5g of a white powder with a hint of pink. I've labelled the bottle "manganese cyanurate?" with no formula as I do not know exactly what it is.

1 wet remainder.jpg - 610kB 2 very pale peach powder 13g.jpg - 599kB

woelen - 10-7-2020 at 01:32

I would not call that pink. I have the impression that the pure compound would be (nearly) white, but that there is a small amount of oxidized manganese (oxidation stater +3 or +4, giving a darker color) in your product. Even a very low percentage of manganese(III) or manganese(IV) (e.gh. 0.1% or even less) can make your product look brown.

I myself have some MnCO3 of decent purity. Normally, this is a very pale pink, almost white powder. My powder has the same color as your powder. Still it is quite pure.

Lion850 - 10-7-2020 at 02:52

Woelen - it certainly looks darker on the previous photo (of the dried product) than with the eye. I’ll take another photo in natural light. The deep purple color of the copper compound got me keen to see which colors other metals may give :)

Edit: Attached photo of the product of the cyanuric acid and manganese powder stirring plus, for interest, some manganese carbonate I made long go. Photo taken outside on a cloudy day.

3 photo of dry product in natural light.jpg - 774kB

[Edited on 11-7-2020 by Lion850]

wg48temp9 - 11-7-2020 at 02:47

I tried a small test at making your copper cyanurate. I only had sodium dichlor isocyanuric acid. (DCA) I put some copper wire in a test tube containing DCA and water. I then gentle heated the test tube in boiling water bath briefly.

After cooling the was a very slight purple sediment on top of the undissolved DCA and some purple blue deposits on the lower part of the wire. Part of the deposit had apparently flaked off. Curiously the upper part of the wire remain bright copper coloured.

I suspect I need to add HCL.

Sorry about the almost useless pic. It was taken outside in the sun so that the colour was not distorted by my LED lighting. I could not see the phone display very well in sun light. Modern mobile phone technology can not compete with our sun. The pic is of the heated test tube to dissolve the DCA to reveal the wire and the precipitate.

Untitled-4.jpg - 31kB

[Edited on 7/11/2020 by wg48temp9]

[Below is a slightly better pic taken with LED lighting showing the colour distortion and the copper wire. The test tube has cooled down so part of the DCA is recrystallising.

Untitled-6.jpg - 20kB

PS: the test tube is now at room temperature. All the copper wire is now covered with a light blue/purple deposit.

[Edited on 7/11/2020 by wg48temp9]

Lion850 - 11-7-2020 at 21:52

wg48temp9 - speaking under correction but I think the acid is Dichloroisocyanuric acid; if it joins with sodium it becomes the salt Sodium dichloroisocyanurate. If you mix a solution of sodium dichloroisocyanurate and a solution of copper sulphate you get the well known purple sodium copper cyanurate complex as precipitate.

I was keen to make a copper cyanurate compound without sodium and chlorine; which I eventually managed by reacting the copper powder and cyanuric acid for 4 days under stirring. But I doubt if much would have happened if my copper was not a fine powder. It probably would have taken much longer with bigger pieces of copper.

Lion850 - 15-7-2020 at 02:47

Cobalt:
Cobalt carbonate (see photo) was reacted with cyanuric acid to see what will happen. Reagent ratios were what I thought was appropriate to arrive at a monosubstituted salt CoH2C3N3O3.xH2O, with the cyanuric acid in slight excess.
- 15g cyanuric acid was dissolved in 150g water, on stirring hot place. Solution was heated to near boiling to get the cyanuric acid to dissolve. pH was approximately 4.
- Cobalt carbonate was slowly added until a total of 10.5g was added. This resulted in a pink suspension swirling around. See photo.
- Temperature was kept at around 50C, After 17 hours the solution was still pink. Temperature was then increased to approx 60-70C.
- After another 2 hours (total 19) the solution was grey. See photo.
- After another 4 hours (total 23) the solution started showing blue-green shades, Temperature was increased to near boiling.
- At the 47 hour mark the solution was blue-green (see photo) but becoming very thick and difficult to stir. Water was added to increase the total volume from 300 to 400 to enable stirring.
- Color remained stable and at the 50 hour mark the heat was switched off but stirring maintained. As the solution cooled slowly the color changed back to more grey.
- At the 65 hour mark stirring was stopped and the grey ppt allowed to settle. The pH of the clear supernatant solution was approx 7.
- The solution was vacuum filtered and the grey remainder washed with excess water in the funnel before being recovered. See photo.
- The remainder was divided in two equal lots. One was taken outside to dry under a steel dish in the sun (still in progress).
- The second part was dried on a steam bath. It started to show hints of color but for most part still grey when fully dry. Dry weight was 11.5g
- It was then put in a crucible in a sand bath at around 220C. After a short time it turned blue. It was kept on the sand bath another 30 minutes and stirred every so often.
- After 30 min there was an occasional hint of an ammonia like smell and the crucible was cooled down. The color did not change during cooling.
- Final weight was 10g, so drying on the sand bath seemed to cause 1.5g weight reduction. The blue powder is very light and adheres to everything. See photo of the final product in the crucible.

I wish I knew what the final product is, I suspect it is some cobalt cyanurate salt but which I don't know. Any ideas from the color?





1 Cobalt carbonate.jpg - 407kB 2 Initial suspension.jpg - 664kB 3 Turned grey.jpg - 542kB 4 Turned blue-green when near boil.jpg - 612kB 5 Final grey ppt.jpg - 620kB 6 Grey remainder.jpg - 527kB 8 Final blue product.jpg - 520kB

Lion850 - 17-7-2020 at 00:52

Cobalt continued:
The grey cobalt cyanurate salt was dried in the sun under a steel dish for 2 days. The final weight is 13g, but although it seems a free-flowing dry powder after grinding I think it probably still has some water. It did not change color, to my eyes it is grey. Which leads me to ask: how common are grey compounds? I have grey metal powders, but this is my most grey compound.....which turns purple on the sand bath, as per previous post.



Grey cobalt cyanurate salt after drying in sun.jpg - 480kB

Bezaleel - 17-7-2020 at 02:25

Quote: Originally posted by Lion850  
Cobalt continued:
The grey cobalt cyanurate salt was dried in the sun under a steel dish for 2 days. The final weight is 13g, but although it seems a free-flowing dry powder after grinding I think it probably still has some water. It did not change color, to my eyes it is grey. Which leads me to ask: how common are grey compounds? I have grey metal powders, but this is my most grey compound.....which turns purple on the sand bath, as per previous post.

I noticed thermochromism in coppercyanurate earlier, see this thread. It seems like you found another example with cyanurate. :)

Lion850 - 17-7-2020 at 03:15

Hi Bezaleel thanks for linking to the thread, interesting stuff. So far I was trying to get coloured metal cyanurate salts while not including alkali metals (or chlorine). But these reactions takes days! Yes the nickel salt in solution goes from grey at room temp to blue-green near boiling and then back to grey again upon cooling. Seems this reverse only happens in water. Not when dry, but more investigation is needed.
I hope to start with iron in the next day or so.

Lion850 - 24-7-2020 at 17:47

Failures:
Chromium: I tried a few different things over many days. Chrome powder was stirred with cyanuric acid solution in different rations, each attempt for some 3 days hot. In each case I got a light brown solution after only a few hours and a gram or so of brown ppt (mixed with unreacted cyanuric acid and unreacted metal powder). Looks like something wants to start but then does not progress.
I tried mixing solutions of sodium cyanurate with chromium iii nitrate solution in different ratios with hours of stirring hot; I did get some 4 gram of a pale green powder (which readily dissolves in HCl giving a beautiful deep green solution); a very poor yield and again apparently remaining sodium cyanurate as ppt as well as nitrate in solution so it seems an equilibrium is reached and the reaction does not proceed.

Iron: I tried to react freshly prepared iron hydroxide with cyanuric acid; what resulted after days of stirring basically was the same dark brown mess as the original iron hydroxide. But something did happen, because a soluble salt formed that resulted in a light brown filtrate when I did the final filtering (when I first made the iron hydroxide the filtrate was clear).

Still a few more things to try....



Lion850 - 25-7-2020 at 02:12

I did a few crude small scale double displacement reactions to see whether anything warranted further investigations. 10gram of sodium cyanurate (most likely the monosubstituted salt NaH2C3N3O3.xH2O) was dissolved in 150ml boiling water; this was kept at boiling to keep the salt dissolved. 15ml of this clear solution was then mixed with the below to see what happens:

Copper sulfate: 1.9g was dissolved in 10g water and the blue solution mixed with the sodium cyanurate. This was a control as the expected reaction was known. And as expected the solution turned purple slowly, and when stirring was stopped a purple ppt settled.

Basic cerium sulphate: 1g was dissolved in 15ml water and the the yellow solution mixed with the sodium cyanurate. Not much happened, if anything the solution became more clear. No sign of any ppt.

Erbium acetate: 1.5g was dissolved in 10g water, giving a pink solution. When this was mixed with the sodium cyanurate the color became slightly more purple but there was no ppt.

Iron sulfate monohydrate: 2g was dissolved in 12g water. When this cloudy solution was mixed with the sodium cyanurate, the color changed to olive green and a pale olive green ppt settled. Where some of the ppt splashed up on the side of the beaker it turned brown. I suspect an iron ii cyanurate formed which was easily changed to iron iii by the exposure to air? This is to be investigated further.

Lead nitrate: 2g was dissolved in 10g water and the clear solution mixed with the sodium cyanurate. The solution immediately went milky white and a white ppt settled.

Nickel nitrate: 1,5g was dissolved in 12g water and the deep green solution mixed with sodium cyanaurate. The solution immediately went lime green and a very pale green ppt settled. The be investigated further,

Tin ii chloride: 1.6g was stirred in 15g water, and the near clear solution mixed with sodium cyanurate. The solution became cloudy and a white ppt formed.

Titanium iii chloride: 1.5g was dissolved in 12g water giving a purple solution. As this was poured into the hot sodium cyanurate solution it first went black (or very dark) and then grey and eventually pale flesh colored. And each time some was poured in gas seemed to be evolved. The solution was filtered. The filtrate was clear. A bit of the wet pale flesh colored remainder was heated in a small crucible to around 200 C, it dried out but kept the same color. Once cooled, concentrated HCl was added. The salt readily dissolved in the hydrochloric acid, giving a clear solution. This surprised me, I was expecting to see the purple color of titanium iii again. A few drops of 35% hydrogen peroxide was added, and it turned blood red which I think support the presence of titanium in solution.
Did the titanium change oxidation state, and is this linked to the gas that seemed to be given off (no smell)?
To be investigated further.

I will appreciate any advice as to how the observations with the titanium may be explained.

sciece nerd - 25-7-2020 at 04:31

A clear solution which turns red when adding hydrogen peroxide indicates the presence of Ti (IV), as the peroxo complex of that is deep red.
I think the basic nature of monosodium cyanurate turned Titanium (III) chloride into strongly reducing Titanium (III) hydroxide (deep blue, almost black) and itself turning into cyanuric acid precipitate, the Ti (III) hydroxide quickly reduces water producing hydrogen (the gas) and is oxidized to white hydrous TiO2. (Hydrogen is immediately produced but it takes quite long for all the Ti(OH)3 to turn white)
The flesh color may be caused by impurities or another unknown compound.

[Edited on 25-7-2020 by sciece nerd]

[Edited on 25-7-2020 by sciece nerd]

Lion850 - 25-7-2020 at 14:26

@sciece nerd Thanks for the explanation. So part of the remainder on the filter paper was fresh TiO2 which then dissolved in the concentrated HCl? This is interesting because my experience with purchased TiO2 is that it does not dissolve in HCl. Being freshly made and dried at lowish temp may be why it dissolved?

When I next get time in the shed I’ll see what happens if a TiCl3 solution is added to a cyanuric acid solution (not the sodium cyanurate salt) thus in a slightly acidic medium.

sciece nerd - 25-7-2020 at 16:37

I think yes.

Lion850 - 25-7-2020 at 20:38

Sciece Nerd for your interest this morning I added some H2O2 drops to the filtrate from yesterday - and there was no color change. So only the remainder gave the red color change (after dissolving it in HCl).

Bezaleel - 28-7-2020 at 02:41

I can confirm that only freshly precipitated TiO2 will dissolve in HCl solution. Both anatase and rutile in particular will not dissolve in HCl, neither after long reflux.

Ti(IV) is colourless in HCl solution, but there also exists a strongly coloured brown mixed III-IV oxide, which forms from Ti(III) solutions on exposure to air. The very intense brown colour arises from a change transfer process (and quickly spoils the beauty of the violet from Ti(III)).

I have seen reduction back to Ti(III) in HCl solution by adding a piece of zinc.

Lion850 - 16-8-2020 at 19:34

Nickel cyanurate

According to "Cyanuric Acid and Cyanurates by GB Seifer" nickel can form either a monosubstituted salt NiH2C3N3O3.xH2O or a disubstituted salt NiHC3N3O3.xH2O. I considered the following equation for the stoichiometry:

2NiCO3 + 2H3C3N3O3.2H2O + 4H2O = 2NiH2C3N3O3 + 2CO2 + H2O2

- 5g cyanuric acid (probably the dihydrate) was added to a beaker with 100ml water and heated to boiling to dissolve with continuous stirring. The water was increased in stages until around 170ml gave a clear solution.
- 3g nickel carbonate was added to the hot solution. Tiny bubbles were observed and the solution was left to stir overnight.
- The next morning there was still some of the larger bits of the carbonate seen swirling around. Another 2 gram of carbonate was added bringing the total to 5g and another 3g of cyanuric acid was added bringing the total to 8g. See photo of carbonate pieces swirling around.

** 8h cyanuric acid dihydate reacting with 5g nickel carbonate and expecting the monosubstituted salt should put the cyanuric acid in excess (and even more in excess if only the disubstituted salt formed). I wanted the cyanuric acid in excess, and not the carbonate, to get all the carbonate to react as I knew excess cyanuric acid could be washed out later with boiling water.

- The solution was left to stir hot for a total of around 50 hours. The level of the beaker was topped up to around the 150ml mark every morning and evening to make up for losses.
- After some 38hrs there was a thick lime green suspension with no more carbonate solid, but stirring was continued for another 12 hours (total around 50). See photo of the final solution.
- The solution was vacuum filtered, and the lime green remainder washed twice with excess boiling water in the filter. See photo.
- The filtrate was very pale green, so the final product is very slightly soluble in water. Once the filtrate cooled to room temperature the solution remained green, but some white ppt was seen, most likely the excess cyanuric acid.
- The lime green remainder was dried on a steam bath until the weight remained stable. Total drying time was around 5 hours.

The theoretical yield was around 8g, if the product was the anhydrous monosubstituted salt. The total recovery was 9.6g, probably due to it being a hydrate.

The only test I did on the product was to add some to concentrated hydrochloric acid. There was no immediate reaction. See photo of final product in bottle.

Neodymium carbonate and cyanuric acid is currrently stirring in the shed. Report to follow once completed.



1 Initial solution.jpg - 690kB 2 Final solution after 50 hours.jpg - 556kB 3 Remainder and filtrate.jpg - 442kB 4 Final product after drying.jpg - 472kB

woelen - 16-8-2020 at 22:58

This looks very much like the carbonate. How can you be sure that the carbonate is fully converted? I can imagine that there is carbonate, covered with a layer of cyanurate.
Another interesting experiment would be the following:
- Add nickel carbonate to some dilute HNO3. Use excess nickel carbonate. Heat this mix and stir for a while in order to be sure that all nitric acid is used up and you have a solution of nickel nitrate. Filter the solution, so that you have a clear solution of nickel nitrate.
- Dissolve NaOH in water and dissolve as much as possible of cyanuric acid in that. The solution should have a pH not above 11. That would be a good indication that there hardly is any free hydroxide left.
- Mix the solutions of nickel nitrate and sodium cyanurate and see what kind of precipitate is formed.
With this experiment you start with all ions in solution and there is no risk of having solid matter, unreacted, which is covered by a thin layer of product.

Lion850 - 17-8-2020 at 00:16

Woelen - I was indeed weary of some carbonate being left over. That's why the cyanuric acid is in excess and the mixture was stirred near boiling another 12 hours after is seemed there was no more change slowly taking place.

The product certainly does not immediately react with HCl as does the raw nickel carbonate. But some carbonate remaining somewhere is for sure a possibility. What I can add to the above report is that product eventually dissolve in the concentrated HCl giving a slightly green solution, no visible sign of CO2 at any point.

If you look at the 3rd post on this page you will see that I previously did a series of crude tests reacting various metal salts with a solution of sodium cyanurate to see what warrants further experimenting, and I wrote for Nickel:
"Nickel nitrate: 1,5g was dissolved in 12g water and the deep green solution mixed with sodium cyanaurate. The solution immediately went lime green and a very pale green ppt settled. The be investigated further"

What I can try is to react a clear solution of cyanuric acid with a solution of nickel nitrate assuming the monosubstituted salt will form and then a 10% or so excess of cyanuric acid. This avoids having sodium in the reaction and thus avoid the possibility of a sodium-nickel-cyanurate complex.

I now also have nickel metal powder. I can stir nickel powder with hot cyanuric acid solution as I did with copper powder. The copper powder eventually gave a beautiful deep purple compound, but after nearly 100 hours!


woelen - 17-8-2020 at 01:25

I missed the remark about the nickel nitrate in your 3rd post. Given your description of the precipitate, I am more convinced that your pale green precipitate you have not indeed is nickel cyanurate. What remains though is the possibility of still having carbonate in it.

Using NaOH as I suggest in my previous post introduces the risk of coprecipitation of sodium ions. I do not expect any serious complex formation with Na, nor any double salt formation. Such things are very rare with sodium ions. What I usually do with that kind of things is letting the precipitate settle (takes one day), then decanting all clear solution above it, and then adding a lot of water again and stirring for a while and letting it settle again. Especially if the precipitate is somewhat slimy and no real crystals can be seen, the contact with the liquid is very good and the sodium can go freely in the water. Each rinse then dilutes the sodium contents with a factor of 10 or 20 and usually with two rinses only a few tenths of percents of the sodium is left. With this, of course, I assume that no complex or double salt is formed.

Lion850 - 21-8-2020 at 01:34

Woelen - an update on nickel:
I dissolved 10g cyanuric acid in 300ml boiling water (all dissolved to clear solution) and then added 2.8g NaOH (forgot to take the pH). To this hot solution I then added a solution of 18g nickel nitrate hexahydrate. A lime green suspension formed. The solution was vacuum filtered, and the lime green remainder dried on a steam bath. The filtrate was still surprisingly green, although not as deep green as the original nickel nitrate solution.

The dry product looks exactly like the lime green powder I got before. See photo showing both. I did some tests on both the products:

When heated to 200+ degrees (in a small crucible with a lid on directly on my hotplate) the color turns from lime green to tan after some 10 minutes. See photo. What the crucible lid is removed (when still hot) there is no smell but only white fumes which looks like steam. The tan color remains the same when it is cooled to room temp, but when the tan powder is wetted with water it returns to lime-like color. See photo. So this change looks purely like a change in hydration.

I added small bits to each of sulphuric acid (>95%), nitric acid (70%), and hydrochloric acid (35%) and stirred with a stainless spatula for a few minutes (at room temp). There seems to be little if any reaction with the sulphuric or nitric acid, but with the hydrochloric acid it slowly forms a pale green solution which has a hint of blue if more water is added.

What surprised me is that the recovery of the lime green remainder once dried was only 6g. I expected more. I'm not sure if some disubstituted salt also formed and stayed in solution; which may also explain why the filtrate was still quite green.

I also wondered whether the nickel nitrate reacted with the NaOH and formed nickel hydroxide; but I would have expected the hydroxide to be easily soluble in all 3 the acids. And photos online shows nickel hydroxide to be more green; not lime green.

What I will try next is to stir nickel powder with hot cyanuric acid (for days) and see if I get something.



11 2nd synth crop.jpg - 426kB 12 After heating to 200+.jpg - 380kB 13 After adding water to the tan product.jpg - 385kB

watercoach - 15-11-2020 at 08:55

Hello. I am new here but found your discussion while searching on Google about cyanuric acid removal. I am a chemist in the swimming pool industry and identified copper cyanurate purple crystals around 1982. No one had every heard of this compound but many pool service techs had seen it but had no idea what it was. I was asked about it and with the help of XRF at Monsanto Company, we identified the compound as copper cyanurate possibly with ammonia. . Copper cyanurate and ammonia complexes are present in swimming pool water. I was the first one to determine that the purple crystals on metal components, plastic and plaster in some pools were copper cyanurate in 1982 with the help of an XRF (x-ray diffraction which was pretty new) and Monsanto Company helping to identify it from the powder print. I wrote about these purple crystals in a training manual I wrote called "IPSSA Intermediate Training Manual" in 2008 but had been telling people about it in seminars since 1983.

And now they discovered that the copper cyanurate is a gem found in small cracks in the rock covered in bat shit in the mountains of Northern Chile, near the border with Perú. You could have a potential income stream from harvesting purple crystals from your poorly cared for pool.

Joanneumite, Cu(C3N3O3H2)2(NH3)2, a new mineral from Pabellón de Pica, Chile and the crystal structure of its synthetic analogue
Abstract
The new mineral joanneumite was found at Pabellón de Pica Mountain, Iquique Province, Tarapacá Region, Chile, where it occurs as violet microcrystalline aggregates up to 2 mm in size in small cracks in a gabbroic rock, which is covered by a guano deposit. Associated minerals are salammoniac, dittmarite, möhnite and gypsum. Joanneumite is non-fluorescent and the Mohs hardness is 1. The calculated density is 2.020 g cm–3. The infrared spectrum of joanneumite shows the frequencies of NH3 and isocyanurate groups and the absence of absorptions of H2O molecules and OH– ions. The chemical composition (electron microprobe data, the hydrogen was calculated from the structural formula, wt.%) is C 20.33, N 31.11, O 28.34, Cu 17.27, Zn 0.24, H 2.82, total 100.11. The empirical formula is Cu0.96Zn0.01N7.84C5.98O6.25H9.96 and the idealized formula is CuN8C6O6H10 with the structural formula Cu(C3N3O3H2)2(NH3)2. Due to the lack of suitable single crystals the synthetic analogue of joanneumite was prepared for the single-crystal structure refinement. The crystal structure was solved and refined to R = 0.025 based upon 1166 unique reflections with I > 2σ (I). Joanneumite is triclinic, space group P1̄, a = 4.982(1), b = 6.896(1), c = 9.115(2) Å, α = 90.53(3), β = 97.85(3), γ = 110.08(3)°, V = 290.8(1) Å3, Z = 1 obtained from single-crystal data at 100 K, which are in good agreement with cell parameters from powder diffraction data of joanneumite at 293 K: a = 5.042(1), b = 6.997(1), c = 9.099(2) Å, α = 90.05(3), β = 98.11(2), γ = 110.95(3)° and V = 296.3(1) Å3. The eight strongest lines of the powder X-ray diffraction pattern are [d, Å (I,%) (hkl)] 6.52 (68) (010), 5.15 (47) (011), 4.66 (21) (100, 110), 4.35 (9) (1̄11), 3.29 (6) (1̄20), 3.22 (7) (1̄1̄1), 3.140 (100) (1̄21), 2.074 (7) (1̄32). The crystal structure of joanneumite is identical with the structure of synthetic bis(isocyanurato) diamminecopper(II).

Just adding to your discussion.


Lion850 - 16-11-2020 at 18:54

Hi Watercoach thanks for the info about Joanneumite. Do you perhaps have a procedure for the lab synthesis of this compound?

watercoach - 17-11-2020 at 07:55

I am sorry. I do not. It is not understood how the copper cyanurate forms in swimming pools. We have plenty of CYA (50 to 200 mg/l) from using trichloroisocyanurate (chlorine tabs) as the chlorine source and there is some amount of copper in the water due to incoming replacement water, erosion, corrosion, copper-based algaecides, and Cu-Ag ionizers. But there must be some other condition that initiates the precipitation of copper cyanurate or else all pools would have the purple crystals. I suspect that the pH in the water gets low (<7.2), copper (>0.5 mg/l) and cyanurate (>200 mg/l) with some amount of chloramine or ammonia present, and then the pH is abruptly raised to ~7.5. UV from sunlight may also play a role. I have seen purple crystals covering metal light rings, ladders and escutcheons. In some cases it covers plastic skimmers and return water fittings.