Sciencemadness Discussion Board

Is it possible to do free radical halogenation with normal lab supplies?

Cou - 5-4-2019 at 09:37

It's the first reaction we learn in organic I, but I've never seen any examples of real world applications.

could you just mix chlorine gas and butane gas in a flask, and shine a UV light on it, then various chlorobutanes would condense? then you could use fractional distillation to separate the difference chlorobutanes

fusso - 5-4-2019 at 10:29

Quite long time ago I tried condensing butane into liquid in a test tube with dry ice, and bubble Cl2 made in situ into the liquid butane to see what would happen. In the middle of the experiment a small fire suddenly sparked and made some weird smell and forming some grey liquid from where the mixture burnt, ruining the mixture.

WGTR - 5-4-2019 at 10:41

https://www.sciencemadness.org/talk/viewthread.php?tid=70963

SWIM - 5-4-2019 at 13:12

If you decide to try this, have a look at the transmission percentages for various wavelengths through different materials.
UVA can make it through borosilicate much better than UVB or UVC.
Get down to 254 NM and transmission through boro is terrible, but it will go through quartz or Vycor just fine.
Get down to under 200 NM, and even quartz stops quite a bit unless it's fairly thin, like a few mm.
I didn't find this out until I bought a 250 mm by 12 mm quartz disc which it turns out is kinda thick for the short wavelengths I wanted to push through it. (anybody need a big friggin' piece of quartz?)

UVC bulbs with a few watts of power are cheap, and require no ballast in many cases, but the ballasted UVC bulbs in water and air duct sterilizers can have much higher wattage and aren't too bad price-wise.

There are 110 volt, and 220 volt UVC bulbs that look like CFLs are available for sterilizing your home (Yikes!) which would be simple to use. The ballast is built right into the bulb base and they go in regular threaded lightbulb sockets.

Getting as much of the radiation into the reaction vessel as possible would be important with these sort of bulbs.
Magpie used a lot more wattage( 80?) when he made carbon tet, but he was using a big borosilicate flask with the bulb outside, so was probably losing a lot of that energy. However there are commercial photochemical reactors that work just that way; and he did get good results.

A quartz flask, or Vycor, is an obvious choice if you've got one, but clamping a quartz disc as a window onto the top of a reaction vessel that has a jacket and a bottom drain could work too.
Vapor rises from a boiler below into the vessel through the bottom drain and hopefully gets condensed on the cooled surface and runs back down to the boiler.
Stick a fractionating column between them and perhaps the halogenated material would tend to stay in the boiler so you might be able to get partially halogenated products in better yield.
This sort of thing might require a baffle in the upper chamber. Something like a beaker with a short tube projecting from the bottom and through the bottom drain of the reaction vessel.

Yungkang quartz makes a quartz dewar condenser like item that should do the trick with one of those UVC bulbs they use to sterilize houses. Just put the bulb in where the coolant would normally go and wrap the outside in something reflective. the geometry of the situation would make for very efficient use of the radiation emitted.

If you're into do-it-yourself equipment, an old lava lamp rewired for a 3 to 6 watt uvc bulb like those ones in toothbrush sterilizers (they take something like 2 VDC) would be a decent holder and reflector for a quartz RBF.

Using a reaction kettle with the regular lid may be a good possibility too if you get one of those quartz jacketed UVC lights for sterilizing water and find a way to jam it in one of the top joints without leakage.

I expect the seals in actual water sterilizer units wouldn't hold up to the hydrocarbons and chlorine radicals it would be subjected to if you just tried to use the unit as a reaction chamber.

Ace photochemical reactors in various sizes show up on Ebay all the time, but seldom have the bulb and ballast.
The big ones are easy to find, but the little ones are less common.
Those reactors use LOTS of wattage, but I suspect they're supposed to work with a single pass through the reactor instead of refluxing stuff around in there for a while.
They are pretty damn expensive with bulb and ballast though. Like a grand or two maybe for a decent looking used one of 1000 ml.



S.C. Wack - 6-4-2019 at 10:09

Quartz tubes (e.g. technicalglass.com) would be a rather cheaper ebay item of interest. Get more than one if you do, because they're probably more fragile than you think they are. The tube (or several connected sections of tubes arranged to suit) can be as long as it has to be with as many lights along it as necessary. A quartz tube from a toaster oven or other heater could be repurposed.

[Edited on 6-4-2019 by S.C. Wack]

Rhodanide - 10-4-2019 at 13:22

You don't even need a UV lamp, actually...
Trichloroisocyanuric acid chlorinates Toluene to form Benzyl Chloride. If you mix them in a flask and leave it outside on a sunny day, it's supposed to proceed by a free-radical chlorination route, or so I've heard.

DavidJR - 10-4-2019 at 17:04

I made a small amount of carbon tetrachloride by bubbling chlorine gas into chloroform while under a UVC germicidal lamp