Sciencemadness Discussion Board

I NEED HELP (FOR MAKING HIGH POWER TRANSFORMESR!)

wish i had a kraken!!! - 19-12-2014 at 01:18

HELLO EVERYONE ,
HERE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=52Oi95St_lY is a link of my homemade HighVoltage Power supply -I made it buy connecting 3 MOTs - , For some reasons I need To make a HIGH POWER HIGH VOLTAGE POWER SUPPLY (Similar to so called bombarder transformers!) But I couldn't find the calculations suitable for making transformers with powers more than 3.5 KiloWATT !

I need help of anyone who Knows the exact calculations nedded for making a transformer with POWER EQUALS TO 9 KILOWATT OR MORE.

Regards
Nima


[Edited on 19-12-2014 by wish i had a kraken!!!]

froot - 19-12-2014 at 02:01

A transformers power is dependent on it's magnetic core volume and operating frequency. If you can see a VA rating on a MOT all you do is divide the required power by the VA rating to get the number MOT's you need. Transformers with normal laminated cores work fantastically at 200Hz and by doing so you can get more than triple the rated power through them. The trick then would be to supply them with 9kW power at 200Hz. Best I can suggest for now is using a variable frequency motor drive.

wish i had a kraken!!! - 19-12-2014 at 05:51

Thanks froot , But I don't want to use MOTs anymore , I want to wind up the Transformer that I need , and I need calculations for that , The area of its core , The Number of turns for primary & secondaries and so on FOR MAKING A BOMBARDER NEON TRANSFORMER.

IN FACT I DON'T KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT WINDING A BOBARDER NEON TRANSFORMER (like the one in the picture or ones here http://www.sinolite-neon.com/ProductShow.asp?id=216)!



[Edited on 19-12-2014 by wish i had a kraken!!!]

New Bitmap Image (6).bmp - 755kB

IrC - 19-12-2014 at 10:41

As lacking in knowledge and understanding of the math and theory you appear to be from your own words I suggest you wait a few more years studying and working on things much more safe than your wild dreams. First off you have not stated the voltage and current required. Second you should be talking KVA not kilowatt. If you need an example of the size required I suggest you look at a 10 KVA pole pig up on a pole in your neighborhood. A pole or plate transformer not an NST is what you are talking about at this power level. Gain more experience and tone down your goals for now. Otherwise you will end up as yet another sad story on SCM. I was kind of hoping after Myfawny we would not have any more stories of this nature. Buy a fork lift while your at it a 9 KVA transformer is not what I would term light lifting. Smaller transformers at such a high power level would be meant for very short duration use. Transformers (high voltage) for continuous use require oil filling for both self healing insulation and heat transport. Even at 240 volts you are looking at almost 38 amperes of current being drawn from your outlet, are you really sure you know what you are doing? Are you qualified to be doing it?

WGTR - 19-12-2014 at 12:31

One thing that may help is to not make one big transformer, but several smaller ones. The smaller cores will run cooler,
all other things being equal.

"Transformer temperature rise is directly
related to the ratio of transformer surface area to transformer
volume; larger cores are thus less efficient in radiating heat losses.
For small cores (WaAc < .5) the graphical Po will generate
temperature rises <40°C; for large cores (WaAc > 1.0) the
graphical Po will generate temperature rises >60°C. " (Power Design, 4.9)

In any case, I would suggest starting small, to learn how magnetics "works". This makes small disasters instead of a
big ones. Mornhinweg gives a generic set of calculations for power line transformers ("Transformers and coils").

Sources:

"Section 4. Power Design." n.d. Lodestone Pacific. Web. 19 Dec 2014. http://www.lodestonepacific.com/distrib/pdfs/Magnetics/Desig...

Mornhinweg, Manfred. Transformers and coils. n.d. Web. 19 Dec 2014. http://ludens.cl/Electron/Magnet.html

jock88 - 19-12-2014 at 12:50


Reminds me of back in the day. The first ever transformer I wound was an (approx.)
10 K Volts out and about 9 KVA. An unruly beast. I HAD NOT GOT A CLUE with hind sight. The input had a variac on it and when taken up to close to 10 KV the output shorted somewhere or other and I had to close things down quick. Then got myself a tank of oil, popped in the transformer and all went well. The transformer needed to be current limited, which it was not. I did not understand what magnetic shunts were all about. Lucky I was not fried alive.



wish i had a kraken!!! - 19-12-2014 at 13:14

Quote: Originally posted by IrC  
As lacking in knowledge and understanding of the math and theory you appear to be from your own words I suggest you wait a few more years studying and working on things much more safe than your wild dreams. First off you have not stated the voltage and current required. Second you should be talking KVA not kilowatt. If you need an example of the size required I suggest you look at a 10 KVA pole pig up on a pole in your neighborhood. A pole or plate transformer not an NST is what you are talking about at this power level. Gain more experience and tone down your goals for now. Otherwise you will end up as yet another sad story on SCM. I was kind of hoping after Myfawny we would not have any more stories of this nature. Buy a fork lift while your at it a 9 KVA transformer is not what I would term light lifting. Smaller transformers at such a high power level would be meant for very short duration use. Transformers (high voltage) for continuous use require oil filling for both self healing insulation and heat transport. Even at 240 volts you are looking at almost 38 amperes of current being drawn from your outlet, are you really sure you know what you are doing? Are you qualified to be doing it?

Dear IrC , you are right and I'm sorry for not talking scientifically , yet I meant I 9000KVA (9000 volts & 1000mA) I'm so embarrassed , sorry . But I KNOW how to wind up common transformers with maximum power of 3.5KVA ,yet I know nothing about bombarder transformers, that's why I asked for help , I think they are a little bit different and I have to figure it out before any further attempts.

wish i had a kraken!!! - 19-12-2014 at 13:25

Quote: Originally posted by WGTR  
One thing that may help is to not make one big transformer, but several smaller ones. The smaller cores will run cooler,
all other things being equal.

"Transformer temperature rise is directly
related to the ratio of transformer surface area to transformer
volume; larger cores are thus less efficient in radiating heat losses.
For small cores (WaAc < .5) the graphical Po will generate
temperature rises <40°C; for large cores (WaAc > 1.0) the
graphical Po will generate temperature rises >60°C. " (Power Design, 4.9)

In any case, I would suggest starting small, to learn how magnetics "works". This makes small disasters instead of a
big ones. Mornhinweg gives a generic set of calculations for power line transformers ("Transformers and coils").

Sources:

"Section 4. Power Design." n.d. Lodestone Pacific. Web. 19 Dec 2014. http://www.lodestonepacific.com/distrib/pdfs/Magnetics/Desig...

Mornhinweg, Manfred. Transformers and coils. n.d. Web. 19 Dec 2014. http://ludens.cl/Electron/Magnet.html

Thanks for the knowledge u shared with me, but I have seen bombarder neon transformers and they are quite big , I have to gain knowledge of winding them.

wish i had a kraken!!! - 19-12-2014 at 13:30

Quote: Originally posted by jock88  

Reminds me of back in the day. The first ever transformer I wound was an (approx.)
10 K Volts out and about 9 KVA. An unruly beast. I HAD NOT GOT A CLUE with hind sight. The input had a variac on it and when taken up to close to 10 KV the output shorted somewhere or other and I had to close things down quick. Then got myself a tank of oil, popped in the transformer and all went well. The transformer needed to be current limited, which it was not. I did not understand what magnetic shunts were all about. Lucky I was not fried alive.



Wow , that was a true beast , could u share with me the calculations u did before winding it ? And was it capable of working at its maximum power for half an hour ?

I have a variac of 10 KVA (220 volts & 40 AMPS(approx.).) Our line voltage is 220 volts .



[Edited on 19-12-2014 by wish i had a kraken!!!]

IrC - 19-12-2014 at 14:08

"Dear IrC , you are right and I'm sorry for not talking scientifically , yet I meant I 9000KVA (9000 volts & 1000mA) I'm so embarrassed , sorry ."

No reason to be embarrassed, and I tend to dissuade people from working with such power levels unless they sound very skilled. Having seen the effects a coworker suffered. Took years of skin grafts and his working days were forever over (at least he got a very large settlement to live on). 10 years later he looked much better but could not move around very well, unable to lift his arms much above mid chest height to this day. He looked so hideous going through years of skin grafting it put the fear of God in me. Try this, find an old welder (Lincoln or similar) which uses the variable core crank handle. Short the welder output together, split the 220 volt plug wiring and use it in series with your large transformer. Dial the core out, as you dial it in power increases. Works better than a Variac at 5KVA plus power levels as a smooth control of power.

franklyn - 20-12-2014 at 09:10

You need to know the power in kilowatts at what voltage single phase the utility can can supply to you. Otherwise you must have a power source of that rating such as a gas generator. 9000 volts output without knowing how , is not something you should try to make yourself. It will almost certainly develop a short circuit. Providing you have a suitable laminated core available , you'll need to use polyimide heavy coated magnet wire and card stock ( Nomex ) or 3mil polyester ( Mylar ) sheet to isolate the individual winding layers. You need to have a Hi-pot tester to test the winding and then start over again if it fails. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1DuDZ3JXjyQ
Immersion in transformer oil is better for cooling than applying thick insulating layers. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B_dJifJvXl0 ( see other videos )

Much better to buy.

Power distribution transformers
http://www.google.com/?gws_rd=ssl#q=pole+pig
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uUc4i4IWhxc ( see other videos )

These are step down transformers , but can be operated in reverse to step up your source voltage. Don't worry about power rating being higher than your needs.

http://www.ebay.com/itm/271711844930
http://www.ebay.com/itm/201065236647
http://www.ebay.com/itm/231286313777
http://www.ebay.com/itm/290934647473
http://www.ebay.com/itm/141211687120
http://www.ebay.com/itm/321617959589
http://www.ebay.com/itm/201234004849
http://www.ebay.com/bhp/pole-transformer


http://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Electronics/Transformer_Design
http://www.schematicsforfree.com/archive/dir/Power+Electroni...

Transformer Design & Design Parameters
http://www.rlc-eng.com/public/IEEE/transformer%20design%20an...

Power Transformer Design
http://www.ti.com/lit/ml/slup126/slup126.pdf

Transformer and Inductor Design for Optimum Circuit Performance
http://www.ti.com/lit/ml/slup205/slup205.pdf

Conventional Transformer Design
http://www.springer.com/cda/content/document/cda_downloaddoc...

Power Transformers Principles and Application
http://www.ssdservice.pl/~ssdservice/SSDdrives/ELEKTROTECHNI...

Electric Power Transformer Engineering
http://prof.usb.ve/bueno/Libros/Electric%20Power%20Transform...

The J&P Transformer Book
ftp://ftp2.epman.org/epman/epman/portal/yde/The_J_P_Transfor...


__________________________________________________________________


Quote: Originally posted by wish i had a kraken!!!  
@ Franklyn, Thanks for your reply to my thread. I have plans to wind up my own transformer capable of providing 9000 volts / 1A . Do you mind if I ask you about the problems I may encounter ?


There's nothing like learning by doing and from the experience of your mistakes. It is the best teacher. There are 1001 things you have to be aware of that are not in books since engineers know practically little of actual manufacturing. I worked at United Transformer Company when it was owned by TRW. It was later resold again and went out of business I believe, in 1989. We made mostly small stuff for chassis. The largest made when I was there was to power the CIWS gatling gun system mounted on U.S. Naval vessels , a 3-phase unit wound of square # 4 magnet wire. There was one dedicated craftsman assembling about 3 of those a month.
http://www.radiomuseum.org/dsp_hersteller_detail.cfm?company...
http://www.junkbox.com/electronics/utc_transformer_catalog_1...
You can still find our stuff for sale http://www.ebay.com/bhp/utc-transformer

The way this works is you must have some idea written up as a plan called a blueprint. Electrical specifications is your problem, you must know and account for that in your design, I'll just take your word for it unless it's obviously unfit or in error. You specify the dimensions , materials to be used etcetera. I can comment on your intended procedure and point out the problems to avoid. Even if you have great handcraft skills, specialized tools and test equipment are indispensable unless you have great faith in prayer. Do yourself a favor and estimate the cost of what is involved beforehand. My best advice now is spend the $ 500 to get a pole pig. You can't go wrong.


.

wish i had a kraken!!! - 20-12-2014 at 09:46

Thanks

franklyn - 20-12-2014 at 17:15

When things go wrong with power lines

Check out the transformer fireworks at time 7:10. Later at time 8:40 , Poof ! goes the workman , never had a chance.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yX5TIDLvMyw

All the power in downtown Manhattan New York , ground fault at the 14th Street Con Edison sub station , Hurricane Sandy 2012.
The ultraviolet emission alone would have sunburned anyone close by.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=seMaLEqotUw

.

jock88 - 23-12-2014 at 06:55


One design item that is very important in large power transformer is their ability to withstand rapid rise or falls in current (caused by say a short circuit). This is something you do not have to worry about as your transformer is relatively small.
If large power transformer are short circuited and are not designed for this situation they will destroy themselves by motor action. Forces acting on the coils will cause them to smash.

The professional books on transformer design are very involved and take all sorts of things into account like Iron losses, Copper loses (I squared R losses, as they are called) max. temp. rise estimations, what type of Iron laminations you may/could use and a whole lot more.

Best approach to take if you just want a relatively small transformer is to take a suitable core area and run from there. The core will already be chosen (from another scrapped transformer) so its a matter of finding out how many 'turns per volt' you have. This can be a very simple formula when things are kept simple and conservative.

Then you decide what current density you will work at in the windings. The lower the current density the less heat will be generated and the better the output voltage regulation.
Around 3.1 Amps per mm squared is very comfortable. (about 2000 amps per square inch if you are that way inclined).
The amount of Copper you are going to wind into the winding must fit into the available space.
Not filling all the available space disproves the output voltage regulation somewhat I believe (not a worry in your case).


When working with high voltage projects very often you want a transformer with POOR output voltage regulation. Examples are neon sign transformers and microwave oven transformers. These have magnetic shunts placed into the transformer for this function. As more and more current is drawn the output V falls. It is usually OK to short circuit the output without blowing a fuse (or worse).
Putting magnetic shunds into E / I shaped laminations is easy enough. I don't know where you would put shunts into C / I
shaped laminations.
The out winding of high voltage transformers are often pyramid wound and the windings have layers of insulation between them what extend all the way out to the core.
Suitable varnish is used too for insulation and holding things together.

Remember that with microwave oven transformers the manufacturer knows that the transformer would always have load connected. By knowing this they can be very skimpy with the number in turns on the input coil. If you plug in one of these transformers and do not connect anything to the output for say half an hour the transformer will get very hot (perhaps damage itself) as there are large currents flowing in the primary due to not enough turns in the winding.


The beast I spoke of above had a welder transformer as a core. It was around 9KW (AFAIKR). Just over one turn per volt. ie. one turn give (or took if on the primary) just less than one volt. There was something like 15000 turns of enameled copper capable of carrying 300mA at around 3.1 amps per square mm. That is around 4.5VA. All very conservative.
It would of course put out far more that 300mA for short periods of time (few amps perhaps).
Insulation between each winding was used. It was stuff that consisted of a layer of paper and a layer of clear plastic (don't know what plastic or ratings) stuck together. I believe it's trade name was Elephant Hide! The output winding was also pyramid wound and varnish applies to each winding layer and the layer of insulation 'stuck' on.
The windings were separated (on separate bobbins).

The primary was the primary that was there in the first place. Old wire that was covered in cloth insulation of some sort (before the days of enameled Copper I guess).

The whole lot had to be put into a tank of transformer oil in order to 'put manners on it', as it was doing quite a lot of 'sizzling' when on the bench. The output shorted to the core too but all went well when put onto oil tank.





Attachment: bbb.zip (1.4MB)
This file has been downloaded 382 times

[Edited on 23-12-2014 by jock88]

jock88 - 23-12-2014 at 07:06


Someone once said that it is good to use the 'buddy system' when dealing with HV. ie Have someone around to plug you out if you get stuck to the system!!

Dudes that make neon signs told me themselves that they work with one hand in their pocked when testing etc (not a joke btw).

smaerd - 23-12-2014 at 09:30

It's not only neon sign manufacturers. People who do work with large currents, high voltages, arc's, discharges, whatever tend to do this. My physics professor told us about the one hand thing, and whenever I tinker with my high amp supply I use it. Making contact with one hand/arm to a source and then creating ground with the other will cause fibrillation which often results in death. It's also good not wear watches, danglng jewelry, or belts, etc. Buddy system is a good idea, sounds like a good idea to have someone who knows what you're up to and can cut the power to what you're working on.

jock88 - 23-12-2014 at 11:12


I had not thought of the one hand idea in terms of one hand being earthed and the other contacting something that it should not, and across the heart to make matters worse.
I had always looked at it in terms of that, since if you were only working one hand it would be easier to stay out of trouble in the first place!

A bit of both perhaps.

wish i had a kraken!!! - 23-12-2014 at 13:53

Quote: Originally posted by jock88  

One design item that is very important in large power transformer is their ability to withstand rapid rise or falls in current (caused by say a short circuit). This is something you do not have to worry about as your transformer is relatively small.
If large power transformer are short circuited and are not designed for this situation they will destroy themselves by motor action. Forces acting on the coils will cause them to smash.

The professional books on transformer design are very involved and take all sorts of things into account like Iron losses, Copper loses (I squared R losses, as they are called) max. temp. rise estimations, what type of Iron laminations you may/could use and a whole lot more.

Best approach to take if you just want a relatively small transformer is to take a suitable core area and run from there. The core will already be chosen (from another scrapped transformer) so its a matter of finding out how many 'turns per volt' you have. This can be a very simple formula when things are kept simple and conservative.

Then you decide what current density you will work at in the windings. The lower the current density the less heat will be generated and the better the output voltage regulation.
Around 3.1 Amps per mm squared is very comfortable. (about 2000 amps per square inch if you are that way inclined).
The amount of Copper you are going to wind into the winding must fit into the available space.
Not filling all the available space disproves the output voltage regulation somewhat I believe (not a worry in your case).


When working with high voltage projects very often you want a transformer with POOR output voltage regulation. Examples are neon sign transformers and microwave oven transformers. These have magnetic shunts placed into the transformer for this function. As more and more current is drawn the output V falls. It is usually OK to short circuit the output without blowing a fuse (or worse).
Putting magnetic shunds into E / I shaped laminations is easy enough. I don't know where you would put shunts into C / I
shaped laminations.
The out winding of high voltage transformers are often pyramid wound and the windings have layers of insulation between them what extend all the way out to the core.
Suitable varnish is used too for insulation and holding things together.

Remember that with microwave oven transformers the manufacturer knows that the transformer would always have load connected. By knowing this they can be very skimpy with the number in turns on the input coil. If you plug in one of these transformers and do not connect anything to the output for say half an hour the transformer will get very hot (perhaps damage itself) as there are large currents flowing in the primary due to not enough turns in the winding.


The beast I spoke of above had a welder transformer as a core. It was around 9KW (AFAIKR). Just over one turn per volt. ie. one turn give (or took if on the primary) just less than one volt. There was something like 15000 turns of enameled copper capable of carrying 300mA at around 3.1 amps per square mm. That is around 4.5VA. All very conservative.
It would of course put out far more that 300mA for short periods of time (few amps perhaps).
Insulation between each winding was used. It was stuff that consisted of a layer of paper and a layer of clear plastic (don't know what plastic or ratings) stuck together. I believe it's trade name was Elephant Hide! The output winding was also pyramid wound and varnish applies to each winding layer and the layer of insulation 'stuck' on.
The windings were separated (on separate bobbins).

The primary was the primary that was there in the first place. Old wire that was covered in cloth insulation of some sort (before the days of enameled Copper I guess).

The whole lot had to be put into a tank of transformer oil in order to 'put manners on it', as it was doing quite a lot of 'sizzling' when on the bench. The output shorted to the core too but all went well when put onto oil tank.


[Edited on 23-12-2014 by jock88]


I used MOTs to build my Highvoltage power supply , And then I used it for making Plasma in a vacuum chamber (after rectifying its output current) , but after 3 minutes
transformers get hot and I really fear that they might damage themselves , (Although I have used safety fuse for them) but I need something really powerfull which can be used for 30 minutes at least , And I came with the Idea to use neon bombarder transformer insted , Latter I felt I really need to make my own bombarder transformer , But I don't Know the differences between an usual transformer & bombarder transformers , I really want to know the calculations , .... etc

I think I am going to Use C/I shunts laminations for that purpose but still need to gather information .


THANKS FOR THE BOOK I'LL READ IT , AND WE'LL HAVE A DISSCUTION SOON.

[Edited on 23-12-2014 by wish i had a kraken!!!]

[Edited on 23-12-2014 by wish i had a kraken!!!]

jock88 - 23-12-2014 at 15:37


What current was going into the vacuum chamber when making the plasma.

wish i had a kraken!!! - 25-12-2014 at 10:15

I suppose 500mA , But I'll check it soon for U


@ wish i had a kraken!!!

franklyn - 25-12-2014 at 13:35

You have to expect that if you run any device in what amounts to a short circuit it has to overheat. If you're running the transformer output with very little resistance or impedance , the important thing is to limit the current drawn from the wall socket. You could also run the MOT with the capacitor as designed. See - Half-Wave Voltage Doubler =>http://www.microtechfactoryservice.com/doubler.html . In that case the capacitor limits the power output to the design rating.

.

wish i had a kraken!!! - 25-12-2014 at 14:41

Franklyn I used three MOTs in this way:




FMZIT5FG5KP8CZ5.MEDIUM(2).jpg - 22kB

[Edited on 25-12-2014 by wish i had a kraken!!!]

jock88 - 26-12-2014 at 12:05


Remember that MOT's have a small amount of primary winding turns. If you operate the circuit above and draw no current from the output, the MOT's will get hot due to the excessive magnetizing current drawn.
Things are not so bad when drawing a sensible current from the secondaries.

wish i had a kraken!!! - 26-12-2014 at 14:22

my Problem is that MOTs get hot when I use to make Plasma in a vacuum chamber , after 3 minutes they get HOT , I fear that I may kill them.

franklyn - 28-12-2014 at 18:42

Heat will kill your components when operated above rated temperature limits. The ' ballast ' MOT , I see has secondary winding connected as an inductive choke and you are running twice the rated voltage through it. Reactance is insufficient to drop that voltage. The components over heat from excess power. The in series MOTs produce full power all the time whether it is used or not. Increase the load ( your plasma setup ) to consume it , or use the primary of the ' ballast ' to run a heater. The voltage you output there will also be twice the rating. A lamp dimmer in series with that heater and ' ballast ' primary can adjust diversion of power from the main circuit.

.


jock88 - 29-12-2014 at 13:51


Remember that the 'usual' domestic microwave oven is rated at about 900 watts but the duty cycle of the oven is low.

The manufacturer assumes that the domestic user will not simply run the oven for hours at a time like you would get in a commercial (hotel kitchen say) situation.

wish i had a kraken!!! - 30-12-2014 at 10:47

Quote: Originally posted by jock88  

Remember that the 'usual' domestic microwave oven is rated at about 900 watts but the duty cycle of the oven is low.

The manufacturer assumes that the domestic user will not simply run the oven for hours at a time like you would get in a commercial (hotel kitchen say) situation.


I know that , thats why I want to make a more powerful High Voltage Power supply .I think bombarder neon transformers are good for this purpose but:
1.I'm not sure
2.I don't know how to make a neon sign bombarder transformer


jock88 - 12-1-2015 at 03:20


A book here gives some info. on HV transformers.

https://archive.org/details/neonsignsmanufac00millrich

wish i had a kraken!!! - 12-1-2015 at 10:41

Many thanks :-)

gregxy - 12-1-2015 at 11:46

What is the impedance of your plasma system? The same current flows in the transformer secondary as in the plasma load. If the load impedance is too low, then most of the electrical power will be wasted heating the windings of the transformer.

Compare a neon sign with an arc welder. The sign has a very long low pressure plasma (an arc of several feet in length) so the impedance (Z) is high.
Therefore 1000s of volts be a few mA of current are used. Z=V/I = 1e6

For the welder, the arc is 1/8 inch in length, 20V at 100A are used. Z =0.2

It takes a high voltage to initiate the arc, but once started the impedance drops dramatically. Try measuring the voltage across the plasma load and
see if it remains high. If it drops sharply then try reducing the number of turns in the secondary. This will reduce the voltage and the secondary resistance to better match the load, but will also reduce the plasma power.

Shorting the primary of the ballast makes it into a resistor which only wastes power.

wish i had a kraken!!! - 12-1-2015 at 13:19

I'll check the impedance , But I noticed when I draw arc from the PSU, after some few minutes the transformers get hot !Does it help ? I think the impedance drop is not the case here !, by the way I want to know what type of solutions U might offer ? Shall I have a resistor in series with plasma ? How can I save the powerful plasma?

gregxy - 12-1-2015 at 16:18

When you draw an arc in air, its impedance drops to ~10 ohms.
The series resistance of the transformer coils for the MOT secondary is probably >10 ohms. Power=I^2*R. I is the same in the arc as the transformer coil so most of the power goes into heating the transformer. Furthermore I is limited by the coil resistance. Here is a paper on arc resistance. You need to work out the arc length, current and voltage
you want and then make sure the transformer resistance is low enough
to supply them.

http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s002020100074#page-...

You will probably need an external HV source to start the arc
or else start it and quickly draw the electrodes apart.

Try using your MOTs in parallel (however they need to be the same voltage
and you need to get the phasing correct). This should give 1/4 the series
resistance and more power to the load.

jock88 - 12-1-2015 at 16:36

Quote: Originally posted by gregxy  
When you draw an arc in air, its impedance drops to ~10 ohms.
The series resistance of the transformer coils for the MOT secondary is probably >10 ohms.............


It is the magnetic shunts in the microwave transformer core that do all the current limiting. The output windings (secondary) resistance has little to do with it.

You can easily measure the current by adding a 'hot' ammeter. Just obtain a cheap moving coil meter that measures a few amps and 'hang' it on the wire (in series of course). Treat it as hot and dangerous of course.

If you can get your hands on a variac you can turn down the output voltage / power as soon as the arc strikes. It will be an expensive option but a good big variac is a good investment for electrical work.

[Edited on 13-1-2015 by jock88]

gregxy - 13-1-2015 at 12:42

The shunts probably do limit the current, but since the transformer is getting
hot excess power is being dissipated in the winding resistance. Anyway it indicates too much current.

If you put 2 identical 1000W MOTs in parallel, you should get 2000V at 1A,
(at least for a while, MOTs are not designed for continuous duty)

From the paper above: V = 29,000 L/I^0.4

Solving for L (the arc length) gives 8.6cm to match the arc to the MOTs.
The equation from the paper is questionable at this low current, the
lowest current they measured when fitting the eqn was 100A. There are
probably better suited papers out there.