KClO4 has a couple of pros and cons. One of the cons is that its "n" exponent in De Vielle's equation (Burn rate = a * Pc^n, where "a" and "n" are
parameters unique to each oxidizer, and "Pc" is chamber pressure) is somewhat higher than AP. For this reason, as your chamber pressures increase, AP
will keep a far more linear burn rate than KP. Case in point, both oxidizers using PBAN as fuel, assuming Kn tuned to yield equal chamber pressures
and burn rate for both oxidizers; AP will have the greater initial burn rate by a smidge (higher "A" value in said equation), but by the time chamber
pressure reaches only 50% more than the starting value, KP's burn rate increase would be 180% greater than AP's; beyond this point, you can imagine
what happens next. Unless you can be absolutely certain that your chamber pressure will either remain constant, or drop off due to throat ablation,
KP can have some nasty surprises in store for you as an oxidizer.
Not to completely crucify KP, as it DOES seem to have (so written because it has been my experience, not proven as an absolute fact) one major
advantage over AP; a much greater inherent resistance to low-pressure burn rate oscillations known as "chuffing". AP seems to hate running at Kn
numbers much under 125, unless significant amounts of metals, metal oxides, or dicyclopentadienyl iron (a.k.a. "ferrocene") are present in the fuel
mix (the ferrocene works like magic; both stabilizing burn rate, and drastically accelerating it, depending on concentration, but, being that there
are rumours running around that the stuff can do practically anything, including curing cancer, I'm not surprised). KP, on the other hand, doesn't
seem to give a hoot about your Kn value; low Kn? NO problem; low thrust. High Kn? Still no problem; either high thrust, or a CATO. Believe it or
not, with the right binder and fuel modifiers, this makes KP a reasonable candidate for a high-output end-burner, with Kn starting at about 40, to as
high as 100, for larger diameter motors.
Hope this helps.
SKWEEEEEK
|