Sciencemadness Discussion Board

Distillation quandary :)

Keras - 1-5-2020 at 03:39

Folks,

I think some of you (at least) are familiar the binary mixture diagram showing that tilted "lentil" shape made up of both the "dew point" curve and the "vapour" curve, where the horizontal axis represents molar fraction of one component and the vertical axis temperature. This graphic tool is used to model a distillation operation, and it can be used to predict the final composition of the distillate, provided that the curves are accurate.

Now, my question is this: when you get a mixture to boil, unless you're at an azeotropic point, the vapour will have a different composition than that of the boiling liquid. Usually, the vapour is richer in most volatile compound, which means that the liquid is going to get enriched in the least volatile one, which pushes the molar composition of the liquid one way or the other (depending what molar fraction you use in your diagram). In other words, to track that shift in liquid composition, the boiling point is going to change, usually increasing since the liquid loses its most volatile fraction. So, how can you end up with a distillate enriched with the most volatile compound since, as the distillation goes on, the temperature rises and the collected fraction gets richer in the less volatile compound? Also, if you keep the temperature constant, the liquid simply stops boiling.

Just curious, and thanks in advance for any enlightening answer :)

Sulaiman - 1-5-2020 at 04:37

Because I'm doing some ethanol distillations at the moment,
and I use alcoholmeter hydrometers scaled in %ABV (alcohol by volume)
I'll explain using this graph :

16abv.jpg - 187kB

Suppose I start with a 16 %ABV ethanol water mixture doing a 'simple' distillation (no fractionating column)
from the graph, the first few drops of distillate will be about 64 %ABV
as the distillation continues the ethanol concentration in the pot will slowly reduce
as proportionately more ethanol is boiled/evaporated off than water
If the distillation is continued to the point where the ethanol concentration in the pot is reduced to 2 %ABV the distillate will be at 16%
So during the distillation the distillate starts at 64 %ABV and slowly drops to 16 %ABV
If all of the distillate is collected in one container then the average %ABV will be about 40
If the distillate was collected in several small 'cuts' then the first cut may be about 60 %ABV, the next about 50 %ABV, then 40 %ABV, 30 %ABV etc.

Keras - 1-5-2020 at 04:55

Quote: Originally posted by Sulaiman  

Because I'm doing some ethanol distillations at the moment,
and I use alcoholmeter hydrometers scaled in %ABV (alcohol by volume) […]

From the graph, the first few drops of distillate will be about 64 %ABV

Agreed.
Quote: Originally posted by Sulaiman  

as the distillation continues the ethanol concentration in the pot will slowly reduce as proportionately more ethanol is boiled/evaporated off than water. If the distillation is continued to the point where the ethanol concentration in the pot is reduced to 2 %ABV the distillate will be at 16%. So during the distillation the distillate starts at 64 %ABV and slowly drops to 16 %ABV.


Of course, if you distil ALL your starting mixture, you end up with the same mixture in the receiving flask, so nothing is gained. The inevitable conclusion is that you have to accept a (hopefully not that big) loss of ethanol to be able to concentrate it in good conditions. You can never recover all of it in concentrated form.

[Edited on 1-5-2020 by Keras]

Keras - 1-5-2020 at 08:07

Ok, this time it worked. I just had to make up with the losses, and I stopped the distillation each time when a third of the mixture had distilled out. I did three consecutive runs and got something concentrated enough to be ignited by a match. Thanks a bunch!