Quote: Originally posted by franklyn | My query relates to another post in which I assert that Ammonia is a weaker
base than Methylamine so it cannot displace it to form NH4Cl with HCl.
According to this _
CH3NH2 •HCl + NH3 => CH3NH2 + NH4Cl
Which appears analogous to the displacement of the weaker base Hydrazine
N2H4 •HCl + NH3 => N2H4 + NH4Cl |
Those are just equations which essentially just define the reactants and the products, but say nothing about the synthesis. Several times I already
tried to explain that bare chemical equations like those do not describe the chemical system. The problem is that it is the whole system (solvent,
temperature, reagent ratios, rate and order of addition, catalyst, stirring...) that defines the reaction results. For example, if you add methylamine
hydrochloride to aqueous ammonia, no product will form. But if you add methylamine hydrochloride to ethanolic ammonia, I believe it is quite likely
that you will obtain a precipitate of NH4Cl. All the parameters are the same, only the solvent changes and the change can be as dramatic as that.
Also, you say ammonia is a weaker base than methylamine. That is true for aqueous solutions where ammonia is about 10-times weaker base, but this is
not necessarily true for other solvents. Compare the pKa values of NH4+ and RNH3+ ions in DMSO and you
will see how things can change. Besides the proton transfer reactions are just one of the many possible driving forces for a product to form - they
are not necessarily the determinative force. |