Difference between revisions of "Alcohol catalyzed alkali metal production"
(Created page with "{{Stub}} The '''alcohol catalyzed alkali metal production''' is an accessible route to obtaining alkali metals, such as sodium and potassium, by reducing their respect...") |
|||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
The '''alcohol catalyzed alkali metal production''' is an accessible route to obtaining alkali metals, such as [[sodium]] and [[potassium]], by reducing their respective hydroxides in a suitable solvent, with [[magnesium]] metal, using a tertiary alcohol as catalyst. | The '''alcohol catalyzed alkali metal production''' is an accessible route to obtaining alkali metals, such as [[sodium]] and [[potassium]], by reducing their respective hydroxides in a suitable solvent, with [[magnesium]] metal, using a tertiary alcohol as catalyst. | ||
| − | This method was first brought to the attention of the general public by NurdRage in late December 2011. Sine then many other amateurs have tried their own version, with various success. | + | This method was first tested on the now defunct [[Versuchschemie]] forum, and was brought to the attention of the general public by NurdRage in late December 2011, when he isolated potassium metal from KOH, using tetralin as solvent, and [[tert-Amyl alcohol]] as catalyst. Sine then many other amateurs have tried their own version, with various success. |
==Summary== | ==Summary== | ||
| Line 12: | Line 12: | ||
===[[Sodium]]=== | ===[[Sodium]]=== | ||
| − | + | In a ground glass flask (round bottom or flat bottom), a stir bar is added, then 40 g [[sodium hydroxide]] flakes and 30 g [[magnesium]] turnings/powder are added to the flask. Then, 125 ml [[mineral oil]] is added to the mixture. A reflux condenser is connected to the flask, and the flask is heated to 230 °C. A tertiary alcohol is used as catalyst, only 1.2 ml are required. The reaction takes 3 days to complete. After completion, the sodium is mixed with magnesium leftovers, and can be separated by melting it in boiling [[1,4-Dioxane|dioxane]]. The yield of this process is around 30%.<ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kJ2C2w8Ntt4</ref> | |
| + | |||
| + | Unlike in the case of potassium, tetralin cannot be used as solvent for this reaction, as sodium rapidly reacts with it. Any hydrocarbon with a double or triple bond that is usually considered inert cannot be used in this reaction.<ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=si3T8kZxO0s</ref> | ||
===[[Potassium]]=== | ===[[Potassium]]=== | ||
| − | + | In a flask, 2.5 g of magnesium turnings are added, then 5 g of potassium hydroxide are added in in the flask and the mixture is gently stirred. 20 ml of [[tetralin]] is added in the flask, as high boiling point solvent. Tetralin is a good choice, since it's denser than potassium metal, so the resulting potassium will flow on it, allowing better separation. A condenser is connected to the flask. The flask is heated to around 200 °C, and 1.2 ml of [[tert-Amyl alcohol]] are added in 0.4 ml portions. You can also add the alcohol in smaller portions, multiple times. After a few hours, small spheres of potassium metal appear, and over the course of several hours, more potassium will appear. Slowly, the small spheres will coalesce into larger spheres.<ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gHgyn-wsxFw</ref> | |
| + | |||
| + | Mineral oil can also be used, and unlike tetralin, it is completely inert to sodium (as long as it's aromatic-free). After one hour of heating the mixture in mineral oil, potassium metal begins to appear as small spheres. 2 hours later, the potassium metal spheres are much bigger. After almost 4 hours since the start, the reaction is completed, and the flask with the potassium metal can be removed from the heating bath. <ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZPaSWfzW7R4</ref> | ||
===[[Rubidium]]=== | ===[[Rubidium]]=== | ||
| Line 25: | Line 29: | ||
==Main challenges== | ==Main challenges== | ||
===Glassware destruction=== | ===Glassware destruction=== | ||
| − | Sodium hydroxide will etch glass. | + | Sodium hydroxide in the presence of water will etch glass at high temperatures. To solve this problem, a small amount of alkali metal is added to a mixture of sodium hydroxide in mineral oil, to remove the water. Adding sodium is not always needed, you can also add lithium metal. Adding magensium metal is possible, but this wastes the more valuable magnesium metal.<ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=av4zfDV5Mng</ref> |
===Water interference=== | ===Water interference=== | ||
| − | The small amount of water present in the NaOH and KOH will lower the yield. | + | The small amount of water present in the NaOH and KOH will lower the yield, as well as slow down the speed of the reaction, as the magnesium metal first has to destroy the water. To solve this problem, a small amount of alkali metal (lithium, sodium, potassium) is added to remove the water, and jump start the reaction. This method speeds up the process, as molten sodium removes water faster than magnesium does, and as a bonus, can increase the yield to above 90% (NurdRage obtained 96%), while also solving the glassware destruction problem, as NaOH and KOH will only attack glass at high temperatures in the presence of water.<ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=av4zfDV5Mng</ref> |
===Choice of catalyst=== | ===Choice of catalyst=== | ||
| + | The hypothesis behind this method is that the reaction between alkali metal hydroxide and the tertiary alcohol produces alkoxides that are soluble in the mineral oil or tetralin, and the dissolved alkali alkoxides are reduced by the magnesium metal to sodium metal, and magnesium alkoxide, which further react with the alkali hydroxide to reform the alkali alkoxides, and the process starts again, until the magnesium or hydroxide gets depleted or the alcohol boils off. Since short chain alkoxides are less soluble in organic solvents than longer chain alkoxides, long chain tertiary alcohols are the best for this reaction. | ||
| + | |||
| + | None of the primary or secondary alcohols work for this procedure, though highly branched secondary alcohols such as 3,4,5,6,6-pentamethylheptan-2-ol (also known as Kohinool) or 1-(2,2,6-trimethylcyclohexyl)hexan-3-ol (known as Norlimbanol) will work, although the yield is terrible, at 34% and 26% respectively. This would suggest that having an alcohol with a very branched chain is important for the performance of the catalyst. [[Carboxylic acid]]s, regardless of their chain length, do not work at all.<ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iqNiSCdOPIs</ref> | ||
| + | |||
Tertiary alcohols lacking a double or triple bond are the only ones that give good yield. | Tertiary alcohols lacking a double or triple bond are the only ones that give good yield. | ||
| + | |||
| + | A good cheap catalyst is 4-terpinol, which is the main component of tea tree oil, at 40 % concentration. Raw tea tree oil will work, but the yield is crap, and the resulting sodium metal appears as very small particles.<ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cbvC3dFjsx0</ref> If the 4-terpinol is distilled from the mixture and used as purer compound, the yield is much better, at 94%, very close to that of the method using 3-ethyl-3-pentanol, which had an yield of 96%. Injecting larger amounts of 4-terpinol seems to lower the yield to around 81%, probably due to impurities and side products. However, due to its alkene bond in its structure, 4-terpinol will slowly break down in contact with sodium metal after 24 hours, and a second addition of 4-terpinol is required. Addition of lithium metal as jump start will also improve the yield, up to 90%.<ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iNbxgdBi4_I</ref> | ||
| + | |||
| + | Here are a list of various chemicals used by amateur chemists as catalysts that did or did not work: | ||
| + | *Primary alcohols: none worked | ||
| + | *Secondary alcohols: no simple and short chain alcohols worked; however, 3,4,5,6,6-pentamethylheptan-2-ol (Kohinool) does seem to work | ||
| + | *Tertiary alcohols: all tertiary alcohols with saturated chain work; tertiary alcohols with at least one double bond work, but they will slowly break down; unrefined patchouli (which contains patchoulol) however, does not seem to work at all. Tetrahydrolinalool, which is made by hydrogenating linalool (lavander oil) will work as well, giving an yield of 95%.<ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iqNiSCdOPIs</ref> | ||
| + | *Carboxylic acids: none worked | ||
| + | *Phenols: none work | ||
| + | |||
| + | ===Stirring=== | ||
| + | While stirring is not required for potassium, when making sodium metal it's absolutely crucial to stir the mixture, otherwise the reaction will take forever to give any results. Although PTFE stir bars can be used, molten sodium will attack it. A better choice would be glass coated stirrers, which resist molten sodium.<ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oiZf-O6vvbE</ref> | ||
| + | |||
| + | ===Separation of alkali metal=== | ||
| + | The alkali metal obtained from the mixture appears as small globules, and separating them from the slag is somewhat problematic, as it's easy to lose them during the separation process. A good method is to slow the stirring over the course of an hour, to allow the small globules to coalesce into larger spheres. The stirring is then stopped and the heat is turned off to allow the molten sodium metal to solidify. To separate the sodium metal from the slag, the reaction product is poured through a [[sieve]] or kitchen strainer, and then washed with dioxane to remove the magnesium oxide impurities. The resulting sodium metal still has some magnesium metal impurities, which can be removed by melting the sodium metal in boiling dioxane.<ref>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rra3N-kaGhg</ref> | ||
| + | |||
| + | ==See also== | ||
| + | *[[Thermochemical dioxane approach]] | ||
==References== | ==References== | ||
<references/> | <references/> | ||
===Relevant Sciencemadness threads=== | ===Relevant Sciencemadness threads=== | ||
| + | *[http://www.sciencemadness.org/talk/viewthread.php?tid=14970 Make Potassium (from versuchschemie.de)] | ||
| + | *[http://www.sciencemadness.org/talk/viewthread.php?tid=2105 unconventional sodium] | ||
[[Category:Synthesis]] | [[Category:Synthesis]] | ||
Revision as of 18:48, 26 November 2018
 |
This article is a stub. Please help Sciencemadness Wiki by expanding it, adding pictures, and improving existing text.
|
The alcohol catalyzed alkali metal production is an accessible route to obtaining alkali metals, such as sodium and potassium, by reducing their respective hydroxides in a suitable solvent, with magnesium metal, using a tertiary alcohol as catalyst.
This method was first tested on the now defunct Versuchschemie forum, and was brought to the attention of the general public by NurdRage in late December 2011, when he isolated potassium metal from KOH, using tetralin as solvent, and tert-Amyl alcohol as catalyst. Sine then many other amateurs have tried their own version, with various success.
Contents
Summary
The general procedure requires the use of an inert high boiling point solvent, alkali metal hydroxide, metallic magnesium flakes or powder and a tertiary alcohol as catalyst. The reaction is done at high temperatures, usually around 200 °C and requires several hours for to obtain a good yield.
Procedure and performance for each alkali metal
Lithium
No tests have been done so far, it likely doesn't work due to lithium's high reactivity.
Sodium
In a ground glass flask (round bottom or flat bottom), a stir bar is added, then 40 g sodium hydroxide flakes and 30 g magnesium turnings/powder are added to the flask. Then, 125 ml mineral oil is added to the mixture. A reflux condenser is connected to the flask, and the flask is heated to 230 °C. A tertiary alcohol is used as catalyst, only 1.2 ml are required. The reaction takes 3 days to complete. After completion, the sodium is mixed with magnesium leftovers, and can be separated by melting it in boiling dioxane. The yield of this process is around 30%.[1]
Unlike in the case of potassium, tetralin cannot be used as solvent for this reaction, as sodium rapidly reacts with it. Any hydrocarbon with a double or triple bond that is usually considered inert cannot be used in this reaction.[2]
Potassium
In a flask, 2.5 g of magnesium turnings are added, then 5 g of potassium hydroxide are added in in the flask and the mixture is gently stirred. 20 ml of tetralin is added in the flask, as high boiling point solvent. Tetralin is a good choice, since it's denser than potassium metal, so the resulting potassium will flow on it, allowing better separation. A condenser is connected to the flask. The flask is heated to around 200 °C, and 1.2 ml of tert-Amyl alcohol are added in 0.4 ml portions. You can also add the alcohol in smaller portions, multiple times. After a few hours, small spheres of potassium metal appear, and over the course of several hours, more potassium will appear. Slowly, the small spheres will coalesce into larger spheres.[3]
Mineral oil can also be used, and unlike tetralin, it is completely inert to sodium (as long as it's aromatic-free). After one hour of heating the mixture in mineral oil, potassium metal begins to appear as small spheres. 2 hours later, the potassium metal spheres are much bigger. After almost 4 hours since the start, the reaction is completed, and the flask with the potassium metal can be removed from the heating bath. [4]
Rubidium
Not tested so far.
Caesium
Not tested so far.
Main challenges
Glassware destruction
Sodium hydroxide in the presence of water will etch glass at high temperatures. To solve this problem, a small amount of alkali metal is added to a mixture of sodium hydroxide in mineral oil, to remove the water. Adding sodium is not always needed, you can also add lithium metal. Adding magensium metal is possible, but this wastes the more valuable magnesium metal.[5]
Water interference
The small amount of water present in the NaOH and KOH will lower the yield, as well as slow down the speed of the reaction, as the magnesium metal first has to destroy the water. To solve this problem, a small amount of alkali metal (lithium, sodium, potassium) is added to remove the water, and jump start the reaction. This method speeds up the process, as molten sodium removes water faster than magnesium does, and as a bonus, can increase the yield to above 90% (NurdRage obtained 96%), while also solving the glassware destruction problem, as NaOH and KOH will only attack glass at high temperatures in the presence of water.[6]
Choice of catalyst
The hypothesis behind this method is that the reaction between alkali metal hydroxide and the tertiary alcohol produces alkoxides that are soluble in the mineral oil or tetralin, and the dissolved alkali alkoxides are reduced by the magnesium metal to sodium metal, and magnesium alkoxide, which further react with the alkali hydroxide to reform the alkali alkoxides, and the process starts again, until the magnesium or hydroxide gets depleted or the alcohol boils off. Since short chain alkoxides are less soluble in organic solvents than longer chain alkoxides, long chain tertiary alcohols are the best for this reaction.
None of the primary or secondary alcohols work for this procedure, though highly branched secondary alcohols such as 3,4,5,6,6-pentamethylheptan-2-ol (also known as Kohinool) or 1-(2,2,6-trimethylcyclohexyl)hexan-3-ol (known as Norlimbanol) will work, although the yield is terrible, at 34% and 26% respectively. This would suggest that having an alcohol with a very branched chain is important for the performance of the catalyst. Carboxylic acids, regardless of their chain length, do not work at all.[7]
Tertiary alcohols lacking a double or triple bond are the only ones that give good yield.
A good cheap catalyst is 4-terpinol, which is the main component of tea tree oil, at 40 % concentration. Raw tea tree oil will work, but the yield is crap, and the resulting sodium metal appears as very small particles.[8] If the 4-terpinol is distilled from the mixture and used as purer compound, the yield is much better, at 94%, very close to that of the method using 3-ethyl-3-pentanol, which had an yield of 96%. Injecting larger amounts of 4-terpinol seems to lower the yield to around 81%, probably due to impurities and side products. However, due to its alkene bond in its structure, 4-terpinol will slowly break down in contact with sodium metal after 24 hours, and a second addition of 4-terpinol is required. Addition of lithium metal as jump start will also improve the yield, up to 90%.[9]
Here are a list of various chemicals used by amateur chemists as catalysts that did or did not work:
- Primary alcohols: none worked
- Secondary alcohols: no simple and short chain alcohols worked; however, 3,4,5,6,6-pentamethylheptan-2-ol (Kohinool) does seem to work
- Tertiary alcohols: all tertiary alcohols with saturated chain work; tertiary alcohols with at least one double bond work, but they will slowly break down; unrefined patchouli (which contains patchoulol) however, does not seem to work at all. Tetrahydrolinalool, which is made by hydrogenating linalool (lavander oil) will work as well, giving an yield of 95%.[10]
- Carboxylic acids: none worked
- Phenols: none work
Stirring
While stirring is not required for potassium, when making sodium metal it's absolutely crucial to stir the mixture, otherwise the reaction will take forever to give any results. Although PTFE stir bars can be used, molten sodium will attack it. A better choice would be glass coated stirrers, which resist molten sodium.[11]
Separation of alkali metal
The alkali metal obtained from the mixture appears as small globules, and separating them from the slag is somewhat problematic, as it's easy to lose them during the separation process. A good method is to slow the stirring over the course of an hour, to allow the small globules to coalesce into larger spheres. The stirring is then stopped and the heat is turned off to allow the molten sodium metal to solidify. To separate the sodium metal from the slag, the reaction product is poured through a sieve or kitchen strainer, and then washed with dioxane to remove the magnesium oxide impurities. The resulting sodium metal still has some magnesium metal impurities, which can be removed by melting the sodium metal in boiling dioxane.[12]
See also
References
- ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kJ2C2w8Ntt4
- ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=si3T8kZxO0s
- ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gHgyn-wsxFw
- ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZPaSWfzW7R4
- ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=av4zfDV5Mng
- ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=av4zfDV5Mng
- ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iqNiSCdOPIs
- ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cbvC3dFjsx0
- ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iNbxgdBi4_I
- ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iqNiSCdOPIs
- ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oiZf-O6vvbE
- ↑ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rra3N-kaGhg
